摘要
骨关节炎(OA)影响近半数成年犬,并带来生理、身体和功能方面的后果。OA的生理影响包括关节炎症、进行性软骨退变和疼痛。在身体方面,OA的变化通常导致肢体力量下降、肌肉萎缩,某些情况下还会出现关节活动范围减小。在功能方面,OA表现为上楼梯、跳跃、玩耍、运动或执行日常活动的意愿或能力下降。这些功能丧失对犬及其照护者的生活质量均产生负面影响。有效的OA管理需要全面且多模式的方法。治疗选择包括营养、营养补充剂、药物、生活方式改变、电物理疗法、手法治疗、治疗性运动、人体工学支持和手术。由于OA是一种慢性进行性疾病,管理策略必须实用、个体化且长期可持续。方案应简化以尽量减少照护者负担,同时最大化临床获益。基础管理包括优化代谢健康和维持理想体况的营养策略。营养补充剂可提供安全实用的辅助支持,以减轻关节炎症和疼痛。当识别到关节疼痛时,非甾体抗炎药仍是可预期有效的一线药物治疗。当初始治疗不充分或安全性考虑限制使用时,应增加额外或替代性治疗干预。持续且结构化的客户沟通对于设定预期、监测治疗反应以及随时间调整管理计划至关重要。成功的OA管理不仅取决于治疗选择,还取决于长期依从性、重新评估和个体化调整。共识驱动的多模式框架为临床医生提供了一种实用且可持续的策略,以优化患有OA的成年犬的预后。
关键词:犬,骨关节炎,治疗指南,体重管理,非甾体抗炎药,营养补充剂,营养保健品,物理康复
引言
骨关节炎(OA)是犬最常见的慢性骨科疾病。它通常由发育性骨科疾病引起,最常见的是髋关节发育不良、肘关节发育不良和髌骨脱位(1)。OA也可能作为获得性疾病的后果而发生,最常见的是前十字韧带损伤(1)。较少见的是,OA可能由其他发育性骨科疾病(剥脱性骨软骨炎、肢体角度畸形、发育性关节不稳)、创伤(如关节骨折)和影响关节的系统性疾病(如免疫介导性关节疾病、冯·维勒布兰德病)引起。OA在大型犬和体重超标犬中发展更快。尽管OA通常在生命早期发生,并可能在生长中的犬中被发现和管理(2),但更常在成年期被诊断和管理。虽然犬OA和疼痛管理已被广泛综述(3, 4),但关于生命阶段如何影响管理决策的关注有限。本文是综述不同生命阶段OA管理系列文章中的第二篇。前一篇文章综述了生长中犬的OA管理(2)。本文综述当前文献并讨论成年犬的OA管理考虑。为OA低风险和高风险的健康犬以及患有临床OA的犬提供建议。无潜在肌肉骨骼结构异常、不从事高强度工作或运动、且不属于早发性OA易感品种的健康成年犬被认为OA发生风险较低。由于本文引用了系列中的第一篇文章(2),建议在阅读本手稿前先 review 该文章。
OA病理生理学
骨关节炎通常呈进行性发展;随着时间推移,新的临床症状出现,现有症状的严重程度和持续时间逐渐增加(5, 6)。骨关节炎的主要后果是局部生理变化,对关节面、关节囊和软骨下骨产生不良影响。关节面发生退变,包括纤维化和磨损。局灶性全层软骨侵蚀常见于发育不良髋关节的股骨头和髋臼背侧缘,以及发育不良肘关节的内侧冠突和肱骨髁内侧。关节囊发生纤维性增厚。骨赘在关节面边缘形成,附着点骨赘在关节内附着部位形成。炎症在关节囊和软骨下骨中持续存在(7)。关节面损伤、关节囊纤维化、骨赘增生和软骨下炎症的程度在犬之间差异很大,即使在单一骨科疾病内也是如此(8–11)。例如,在髋关节发育不良中,一些关节形成大骨赘而另一些则不形成(9)。发育不良髋关节中的骨赘形成在年轻犬和绝育雌性犬中进展更快(8)。继发于关节囊纤维化和潜在关节周围粘连的关节活动度丧失也差异很大(9)。骨关节炎关节中严重的关节活动受限可能导致肢体使用和步态明显受损。与骨关节炎相关的炎症严重程度可能对持续性疼痛和功能障碍有重大贡献(10)。
主观上,患有骨关节炎的成年犬通常以特定特征就诊:与严重炎症相关的肢体废用或继发于慢性疼痛的功能下降、肌肉萎缩和关节活动度降低。患有严重炎症的犬通常为年轻成年犬。在这些病例中,炎症可能从疾病早期持续存在,或由过度活动触发,这种现象被称为“周末战士综合征”,即平时不活跃的犬进行剧烈运动后表现出骨关节炎症状。进行性功能丧失和肢体使用受损的犬更常见于中年至老年犬。其症状逐渐发展。主人通常描述它们不如以前快乐和活跃。评估成年骨关节炎犬中炎症、慢性疼痛、肌肉萎缩和关节活动度降低的相对贡献可以指导选择最合适的管理策略。尽管犬和人类在骨关节炎方面有许多相似之处(12),但犬的结构变化通常比人类更明显,进展更快(13, 14)。在从人类骨关节炎管理中推断证据时应考虑这些差异。
犬骨关节炎中疼痛的临床表现也差异很大,从细微体征(轻微重心转移、轻度或间歇性跛行)到严重的致衰弱性疼痛(肢体废用、不负重跛行)(9)。疼痛表现的变异性归因于局部伤害性感受放大和中枢敏化,以及神经病理性 and 心因性疼痛成分。关于这些不同机制的相对贡献,犬的知识比人类少(15)。在缺乏关于伤害性、神经病理性 and 心因性疼痛作用的明确信息的情况下,临床医生应依赖仔细的临床评估。严重的临床症状提示至少涉及一种或多种这些疼痛机制,需要进行全面的多模式疼痛管理。
骨关节炎的诊断
由于骨关节炎的影响在犬之间差异很大,无论是每种骨关节炎病因内还是不同骨关节炎病因之间,因此在初次就诊时建立身体和功能基线至关重要。骨关节炎的发现通常由主人对步态或活动能力的担忧所促使,但也可能来自骨科筛查,特别是对于用于繁殖、运动或工作的犬。在某些情况下,骨关节炎是偶然发现的,例如在腹部X光片上注意到髋关节骨关节炎。
骨关节炎的基线诊断应确定受累关节,并描述每个受累关节问题的严重程度。严重程度评估包括疼痛评估(触诊反应、肢体废用)、身体变化(关节活动度丧失、肌肉萎缩)和功能损害(行走、玩耍或执行日常活动意愿降低)。因此,诊断应包括彻底的骨科检查以评估疼痛严重程度和结构变化,以及至少一份经过验证的主人问卷(16)以评估功能影响。有几种经过验证的工具可用,包括Canine Brief Pain Inventory(CBPI,2007)、Helsinki Chronic Pain Index(HCPI,2009)、Liverpool Osteoarthritis in Dogs score(LOAD,2009)和Canine Orthopedic Index(COI,2014)(16)。COI(14分)和LOAD(4分)已有最小临床重要差异的报道(17)。CBPI似乎是使用最广泛的客户报告结局指标。纳入问卷尤为重要,因为不到一半的骨关节炎犬表现出主人容易识别的跛行(14, 18)。
尽管骨科检查可能强烈提示骨关节炎,但确诊通常需要诊断性影像学检查,正如在生长发育中的犬只中所见(2)。放射摄影最常用于基于骨赘和附着点骨赘的识别来确认骨关节炎(8)。当重叠投影限制了放射摄影的敏感性时,可能需要计算机断层扫描(CT),尤其是在肘关节,因为放射摄影对内侧冠突碎裂的检测敏感性有限(2)。CT在跗关节、腕关节及其他复杂关节中也可能有用,并可用于量化骨关节炎的严重程度(19)。总体而言,影像学发现与临床严重程度之间的相关性较弱。在一项针对肘关节骨关节炎犬只的研究中,临床可检测的疼痛与放射学骨关节炎严重程度之间的相关性较差,而疼痛与使用正电子发射断层扫描识别的组织炎症之间的相关性更强(10)。关节镜检查也可用于诊断骨关节炎,并可将诊断评估与治疗干预相结合。例如,肘关节镜检查可以确认骨关节炎并允许移除碎裂的内侧冠突。小直径(针式)内窥镜减少了侵入性(20),尽管其同时进行治疗的能力比传统硬性关节镜更为有限。准确诊断在运动犬和工作犬中尤为重要,因为骨关节炎相关疼痛可能对训练和表现产生不利影响。使用主人问卷、观察和触诊进行定期筛查可能提高这些群体中早期发现的可能性。
总之,骨关节炎可通过主人关注、筛查问卷、临床检查或偶然的影像学发现来识别。临床症状的严重程度与影像学上结构改变的严重程度并不一致相关,但可能更密切地反映受影响关节内及周围组织炎症的程度。
患有骨关节炎的成年犬的整体健康
关于骨关节炎疼痛体征和预期疾病进展的客户教育是成功长期管理的基础。客户应了解,随着骨关节炎进展,临床症状可能包括关节肿胀、触诊疼痛、活动范围减小、僵硬、肌肉萎缩、肢体使用减少和活动能力下降。功能性变化如爬楼梯困难、跛行、起身困难或无法跳跃也常与成年犬的骨关节炎疼痛相关。疼痛的犬只可能退出互动或在被触摸时表现出易怒或攻击性。这些行为变化可能使骨关节炎管理复杂化,并可能给家庭内关系带来压力。
随着活动能力下降,家庭内的环境挑战变得越来越相关。例如,犬只可能难以爬陡峭的楼梯或在湿滑的地板上行走。尽管这些挑战通常与老年犬相关,但它们经常在中年成年犬中开始出现。建议进行环境改造,如地毯、垫子或地毯跑道,可能有助于改善牵引力和安全性。抬高食物和水碗可以增强舒适度,坡道可能比台阶更有效地促进通行。
整体健康支持生活质量和长期疾病控制。它包括对生活方式结构、营养和运动的刻意关注。建立一致的日常作息可以提高依从性并最大限度地减少恐惧、挫败感和焦虑。应尽早收集基线功能信息,以便主人能够识别并报告可能表明疾病进展或急性发作的活动能力、活动水平或行为方面的有意义变化。
主人与兽医顾问之间的协作关系至关重要。管理决策应反映主人期望的参与程度、追求不同证据水平支持疗法的意愿、财务考虑以及关于家庭护理与诊所护理的偏好。主人与患者护理管理团队之间清晰、持续的沟通有助于及时调整管理策略并支持可持续的长期护理。
营养计划应支持维持精瘦的体况。如果犬只超重,应向犬主提供结构化指导,包括饮食建议、热量目标和适当的体重减轻速率。可根据个体患者需求讨论和实施营养补充。
运动与玩耍应纳入犬的日常作息,因为较高的活动水平与较少的跛行临床症状相关(9)。活动应根据犬和主人的具体情况个体化制定。犬应逐步进行体能适应,主人应接受培训以识别疲劳或疼痛的迹象。应明确运动的强度、频率和持续时间,并在适当情况下制定结构化计划以改善力量和耐力。应建立前瞻性计划,以便在OA急性发作时或当临床症状加重持续与特定运动或工作量相关时,调整活动类型、强度或持续时间。还应训练犬养成适当的行为,避免拽绳及其他适得其反的行为模式,因为拽绳似乎会对散步的质量、持续时间和频率产生负面影响(21)。对于运动犬和工作犬,全身健康包括平衡训练和表现需求与恢复。必须在训练计划中有意识地纳入休息,以预防过度使用性损伤和慢性应激。
全身健康:关键要点
全身健康是管理成年犬OA的基础。持续且适当调整的生活方式、优化营养、结构化运动以及平衡的工作或运动参与,有助于维持力量和体能,降低OA急性发作的可能性,并支持对OA的长期持续控制。
患有OA的成年犬的身体健康
体况
体能是指犬高效有效地执行功能性活动的能力。它涵盖心血管和呼吸系统健康、肌肉骨骼力量、耐力和敏捷性。体能良好的犬预期表现出更好的活动性和灵活性、改善的整体心血管适能、改善的运动恢复以及降低的慢性疾病风险。优化体能可促进健康寿命——即处于良好健康状态、免于慢性疾病和残疾的生命时期(22, 23)。
衰老通常与肌肉骨骼变化相关,包括肌肉量减少和全身性肌少症(23)。肥胖(脂肪蓄积)是指体脂肪相对于瘦体重的比例。理想体况对应于9分制体况评分(BCS)中的4分或5分(24)。超重犬(BCS 6/9)携带过多脂肪组织,肥胖犬(BCS ≥ 7/9)通常超过理想体重20%或更多。过度脂肪蓄积对整体健康产生负面影响:超重犬面临糖尿病、心脏病和OA等全身性疾病的风险增加,且预期寿命较短(6, 25)。它们的耐力也降低,对过热的易感性增加(26)。随着犬衰老,其体脂百分比通常增加,尽管在非常高龄的犬中可能观察到体重减轻(23, 27)。体能与肥胖呈负相关,尽管犬可能超重但身体状况良好,或偏瘦但体能状况差。许多犬超重或肥胖(28, 29),且主人经常低估其犬的体况;超过三分之一的主人可能无法准确评估BCS(28, 30)。由于结构化训练,运动犬和工作犬的体能水平预期高于久坐犬。在一项研究中,运动犬的平均体脂百分比(13.8 ± 5.3%)低于非运动犬(19.1 ± 8.6%)(30)。 excess体重在OA管理中具有临床意义,因为它加剧全身性炎症和犬的OA症状(25, 31, 32)。
去势会增加体重增加的风险(2),即使在成年期进行(33),并且与某些骨科疾病风险增加相关,包括髋关节和肘关节发育不良以及前十字韧带损伤(34–36)。在一项研究中,绝育雌性犬的OA进展更快,可能与雌激素缺乏有关(8)。当犬具有理想体况时,应实施协作营养计划以维持该状态。对于超重犬,结构化支持应包括计算每日能量需求、饮食建议(包括应避免的食物)、目标体重和安全减重速度。应根据具体患者需求讨论并实施营养补充。
犬肥胖是一种复杂的代谢性疾病,常与骨关节炎(OA)患犬并存。成功的减重方案需要实现受控的负能量平衡,同时保留瘦体重(LBM)并预防营养缺乏。治疗性日粮需要具有较高的蛋白质与热量比。临床指南建议蛋白质干物质(DM)含量>30%至40%,或每1,000 kcal含>85 g蛋白质,以在脂解过程中支持肌肉维持。限制脂肪(通常至8%至12% DM)是降低犬粮总体热量密度的主要方法。然而,配方仍必须提供充足的必要脂肪酸(如亚油酸)以维持表皮屏障功能(37)。提高纤维含量(通常为10%至15% DM或更高)可稀释能量密度,并通过胃扩张和延迟排空促进饱腹感,实验已显示其有效性。然而,临床上它可能无法提供长期饱腹感所需的胃填充感。最佳日粮使用主要以不可溶性纤维为主进行增容、少量可溶性纤维支持血糖和微生物组的混合方案(37)。不建议通过限制标准日粮进行减重,因为这存在微量营养素缺乏的风险。因此,专门配方的治疗性日粮是最佳选择,其提供较高的营养素与热量比,确保在限制热量的情况下仍满足每日100%的维生素和矿物质需求。许多此类日粮含有较高蛋白质,以在减重期间保留瘦体重(LBM)。此外,可添加omega-3脂肪酸以调节炎症和支持关节健康。然而,许多减重日粮中的omega-3浓度不足以缓解与OA相关的炎症。为获得最佳效果,从业者应使用患者的理想体重(IBW)计算每日热量目标。对于减重计划,饲喂犬的热量基于静息能量需求(RER),公式为:RER = 70 x (IBW kg)0.75。减重计划通常从饲喂对应于IBW的RER的80%开始。每两周至每月监测体重和体况评分(BCS)对于调整摄入量和确保每周安全减重1%至2%至关重要。易肥胖犬的体重维持计划也应包括中等偏高的蛋白质摄入,以保留LBM并支持健康的基礎代谢率。处于体重维持计划的犬应按理想体重的RER进行饲喂(37)。
活动与运动
体成分与身体活动密切相互关联,共同影响犬的肌肉骨骼健康及OA的临床表现。历史上,常建议患有OA的成年犬限制活动,部分原因是运动后可能发生暂时性跛行加重(38)。然而,从长期来看,较高的活动水平与OA患犬较少的跛行临床症状相关(9)。同样,运动可减轻膝关节OA患者的疼痛并改善功能(39)。因此,应将运动和玩耍纳入犬的日常作息。活动必须根据个体患者和主人进行调整。应训练犬进行适当的运动行为,避免牵拉牵引绳及其他降低活动舒适性、安全性和有效性的模式(21)。应建立运动的基线强度、频率和持续时间,并在适当时制定结构化计划以提高力量或耐力。
运动计划应与犬的功能目标一致,无论是维持一般体能、进行休闲玩耍,还是为运动或工作做准备。主人和训练师应始终注意特定活动相关的风险。例如,在一项研究中,每日徒步或跑步与敏捷犬前十字韧带损伤风险增加相关(40)。必须识别并处理疲劳或不适的迹象。应制定前瞻性计划,在症状发作期间或当临床症状加重持续与特定工作量相关时,调整活动类型、持续时间或强度。
物理康复
对于接受物理康复的成年OA患犬,管理计划应考虑患者和主人两方面因素。患者因素包括年龄、体型、性情、训练状态、疼痛和功能障碍的严重程度,以及合并症或症状发作风险因素的存在。主人因素包括目标、经验、动机、可用时间、经济资源、协助运动的身体能力,以及可能影响康复计划依从性的其他实际限制。康复计划考虑活动的类型、频率、强度和持续时间。具有较多风险因素或更严重临床表现的犬通常需要更渐进和多方面的管理方案(41)。宠物犬和工作犬的预期结果不同。宠物犬理想情况下应在日常活动和玩耍中感到舒适。相比之下,工作犬预期能在没有功能限制的情况下执行其职业或运动活动。
在开始或加强运动计划之前,必须尽可能减轻疼痛。通常首选能够实现充分疼痛控制的最简单方法。对于某些犬,仅通过药物即可管理疼痛。对于其他犬,有效的疼痛控制可能需要联合药物治疗、营养补充、电物理疗法或手法治疗。一旦疼痛得到充分控制,治疗性运动便成为骨关节炎管理的核心组成部分。随着犬逐步实现治疗目标,运动强度和时间逐渐增加。活动之间的休息时间应个体化调整,以防止疲劳、运动表现下降或临床症状复发。随着时间的推移,管理计划往往变得更加简单,并越来越多地依赖主人实施的护理,如家庭运动计划和日常活动,以维持体能的同时避免症状发作。
患者评估
患者评估对于制定个体化治疗目标、创建骨关节炎管理计划以及选择评估治疗反应的结局指标至关重要。评估通常包括观察和分析步行、小跑及选定功能活动(如爬楼梯)中的站姿和步态。评估还包括一般体格检查、详细的骨科检查和简短的神经学检查,以排除并发的脊柱疼痛或共济失调。骨科检查包括评估关节活动和稳定性、使用关节角度计测量关节活动范围、肢体周径测量以及功能性活动能力和力量评估。基线评估应包括客观和主观指标的详细记录,以便随时间监测治疗反应和疾病进展。全面的康复评估在其他资源中有更详细的描述(41–44)。影响骨关节炎管理计划制定的关键参数将在下文讨论。
关节活动范围(ROM)
骨关节炎可导致关节活动丧失;然而,并非所有受骨关节炎影响的关节都表现出活动丧失,且受限程度在犬之间差异很大(9)。关节活动范围(ROM)通常在基线和随访检查时测量,尤其是在观察到或怀疑关节活动异常时。充足的关节活动是犬无限制站立和移动的必要条件。ROM降低可对活动能力产生负面影响(例如,限制爬楼梯或从坐位转换为站立的能力),可能加剧慢性疼痛,并可能导致其他关节、脊柱及相关肌肉组织的代偿性改变。因此,当关节缺乏正常日常活动所需的活动度时,增加关节活动是一项重要的治疗目标。
关节活动范围通常使用关节角度计测量,测量时将角度计与关节近端和远端的解剖标志对齐,同时被动地使肢体进行屈曲和伸展运动,以度量关节角度(45)。活动受限的严重程度有助于指导治疗干预,如针对性运动、手法拉伸和关节松动技术(46)。关节角度计测量提供客观数据,可用于监测治疗反应或检测与疾病进展相关的恶化(47)。传统关节角度计价格低廉、易于使用,且已被证明比智能手机或数字测量工具提供更高的准确性(48)。解剖标志和正常关节活动范围已有描述(43, 44, 47, 48)。个体犬的站立关节角度也存在差异;有些表现出更直立的姿势,而另一些则保持更屈曲或蜷缩的站姿(49)。
肌肉量评估
与疼痛、骨关节炎和代偿性步态模式相关的负重减少通常会导致肌肉萎缩。因此,应在基线时测量肌肉周径,并在治疗期间定期监测。有多种技术可用于评估肌肉量,包括肢体周径测量、超声、CT、MRI和双能X线吸收测定法(DEXA)(50–52)。肢体周径测量是临床环境中最实用的方法,因为它简单且廉价。然而,测量结果受所用技术的影响,必须一致地进行测量,以便随时间进行有意义的比较(13, 50, 51, 53)。
功能性活动能力和力量评估
在人类物理治疗中,功能性活动能力测试、力量评估和任务特定挑战通常用于确立治疗目标、设计治疗方案并提供可测量的结局(54–59)。类似的功能评估工具已被探索用于犬,尽管其验证仍然有限(43)。 proposed用于评估犬活动能力的测试包括计时起立行走测试、Cavaletti横杆、8字形行走和从卧到站测试(43)。计时起立行走(TUG)测试最近已在犬中得到验证,通过记录犬从静止位置起身并行走短距离所需的时间,提供了一种实用且客观的功能性活动能力测量方法(60, 61)。这些测试可能提供有关功能表现的有用信息,并可能有助于监测活动能力随时间的变化。
活动监测和可穿戴传感器
活动监测已被用于评估犬的活动能力和活动模式。一般来说,体型较大和年龄较大的犬往往比年轻和体型较小的犬活动量更少(62)。一项研究报告称,患有骨关节炎的犬在给予镇痛药物后活动量增加约20%(63),而另一项研究未检测到减重后活动量发生变化(64)。早期活动监测系统因准确性有限(65)以及活动水平与活动能力或疼痛的临床测量之间关系的不确定性(66)而被认为具有一定主观性。然而,传感器技术和数据分析的进步改善了可穿戴活动监测器的性能(67, 68)。因此,其在犬骨关节炎治疗临床试验中作为客观结局指标的使用有所增加(69, 70)。
管理方案
治疗性运动被认为是犬骨关节炎物理康复的基石,因为它直接针对力量、活动能力和功能容量。运动方案通常包括静态和动态活动。静态运动强调姿势控制和基础稳定性,这对所有患者都很重要,无论其临床患者特征、骨关节炎严重程度、活动水平或运动需求如何。一个结构化示例是宾夕法尼亚大学宾夕法尼亚兽医学院工作犬中心开发的Fit to Work项目(39)。该项目包括体能评估、结构化运动以及针对个体犬定制的渐进式运动进阶。
步行是犬最常见的运动形式,已在多项研究中进行了评估。与有限的日常运动(<20分钟/天)相比,较长的日常运动时间(>60分钟/天)与髋关节发育不良犬跛行严重程度的降低相关(9)。上坡和下坡行走也已被评估其对关节运动的影响,并可纳入针对性运动方案(58, 59)。可用于选择性影响关节活动范围的其他动态运动包括Cavaletti杆和楼梯运动(58, 59, 71–75)。这些运动可根据期望的关节效果(例如,改善髋关节伸展或肘关节屈曲)以及所针对的特定肌群进行选择、修改和进阶。对于每项运动,应根据犬当前能力和主人因素选择基线频率、强度和持续时间。这些参数随时间推移根据治疗反应和主人维持运动方案的能力进行修改。
水疗涉及水的治疗性使用,通常包括水下跑台运动和游泳(76)。水下跑台治疗和游泳之间的关节运动效果差异显著,这可在需要特定活动范围或负荷效果时影响治疗的选择。水下跑台治疗允许控制性负重运动,而游泳通常产生更大的关节屈曲且肢体负荷最小。水下跑台运动期间的肌肉激活也因水深而异,这是由于肢体运动与水的物理特性之间的相互作用。因此,调节水位可影响治疗期间的关节负荷、活动范围和肌肉募集(77, 78)。
手法治疗包括按摩、牵伸、关节松动术、肌筋膜松解和牵引。这些技术可协助肌肉骨骼疼痛的评估和治疗。触诊受累组织可提供有关关节运动或组织压迫相关疼痛来源和严重程度的有价值信息。被动活动范围(PROM)运动提供无痛性感觉刺激,可减轻肿胀,并轻柔牵伸关节周围组织。据报道,PROM可缓解某些患者的疼痛(79)。许多主人可被训练在家中执行PROM运动。按摩也可能通过提供非伤害性感觉刺激、改善静脉和淋巴引流以及可能促进内啡肽和5-羟色胺释放而对骨关节炎犬有益。在膝关节骨关节炎患者中,手法治疗联合运动已被证明比电物理疗法联合运动提供更大的益处(80)。尽管按摩已在骨关节炎患者中显示出益处(81),但评估手法治疗用于犬慢性疼痛管理的对照研究仍然有限(82–85)。
光生物调节疗法(PBMT),也称为低强度激光疗法或冷激光疗法,利用特定波长的光影响细胞活动。PBMT可能通过改变外周和中枢神经化学、传入神经传导和内啡肽释放来影响疼痛感知,从而提高疼痛阈值。PBMT还产生多种生理效应,包括增加肌成纤维细胞活性、增强胶原蛋白和软骨合成、增加腱细胞和肌细胞活性,以及通过改变线粒体氧利用来增加ATP产生。其他效应包括通过血管生成和血管舒张改善血流,以及刺激外周和中枢神经系统的轴突发芽(86)。评估PBMT在犬中应用的临床试验结果不一,可能由于样本量小和治疗方案差异所致(87, 88)。犬PBMT的最佳剂量参数仍然未知。
脉冲电磁场疗法(PEMF)调节钙-钙调蛋白-一氧化氮级联反应并下调IL-1β,从而减轻炎症(89)。在人类中,PEMF在治疗膝骨关节炎方面已显示出小到中等程度的益处(90–92)。在犬中,随机对照研究显示其可减轻术后疼痛和骨关节炎相关疼痛,并改善胸腰段椎间盘突出后的神经功能恢复(93, 94)。兽医临床使用的PEMF设备通常通过环状线圈或治疗垫传递治疗。
体外冲击波疗法使用高能声波,当声波遇到组织密度变化时释放机械能。冲击波疗法刺激细胞因子和生长因子的产生、内皮型一氧化氮合酶(eNOS)和骨形态发生蛋白(BMP)的表达。在兽医领域,ESWT最常被研究用于治疗肌腱和韧带损伤以及刺激骨骼愈合,而非专门用于骨关节炎管理(95, 96)。然而,人体研究表明ESWT可能对骨关节炎治疗有益(97–99)。
热疗——冷疗可减轻炎症、组胺释放和水肿。它还可能通过减少肌肉痉挛、降低前列腺素浓度和减慢神经传导来减轻疼痛。热疗可增加血流、促进肌肉放松并改善组织延展性(100–106)。
针灸调节外周、中枢和自主神经系统的活动。针灸通过释放神经化学物质改变疼痛通路,包括脑啡肽、内啡肽、强啡肽、5-羟色胺、去甲肾上腺素、谷氨酸、神经激肽和大麻素(107, 108)。最近,研究聚焦于针灸作为神经调控干预手段,能够影响疼痛相关神经可塑性(痛觉过敏/异常性疼痛)并减少脊髓神经炎症(109, 110)。探讨针灸用于骨关节炎管理益处的随机对照试验结果不一(111–113),但随着更多试验的开展,支持针灸用于骨关节炎管理的证据体正在不断增加。
环境改造是針對执行日常活动有困难的犬的人体工程学策略。改造可包括改善地面防滑性、安装坡道、调整寝具,以及调整食盆和水盆的高度和位置。其他支持措施包括足部护理(如修剪指甲、修剪毛发和防滑辅助装置)以及移动辅助设备,包括胸背带和助行车。
基于骨关节炎风险实施康复策略
物理康复规划将患者评估结果与主人目标、期望和实际考虑相结合(41, 74)。个体化运动计划和活动调整构成骨关节炎犬康复计划的基础(41)。可根据患者需求和现有支持证据纳入其他疗法,包括手法治疗、电物理 modalities 和环境改造。由于不同康复干预措施的证据强度各异,应优先选择有可靠科学数据支持的策略。
健康成年犬/低骨关节炎风险
即使犬就诊时主人无担忧,康复评估也可能有益,因为潜在问题否则可能未被发现。可能的发现包括轻度结构异常、肌筋膜触发点、肌肉紧张、柔韧性下降或肌肉失衡(114)。当骨关节炎风险因素极少时,康复规划主要侧重于维持体能、瘦体重和肌肉骨骼力量。运动计划通常强调一般体能训练,并根据犬的日常活动、运动参与或工作角色进行定制。
健康成年犬/高骨关节炎风险
骨关节炎风险增加的犬受益于定期重新评估,以检测步态、姿势、活动能力或触诊疼痛反应的早期变化。除维持一般体能外,运动计划可针对易于发生骨关节炎的关节进行强化。例如,髋关节松弛且髋骨关节炎发生风险高的犬可能受益于旨在强化臀肌和大腿肌肉组织的运动,以改善关节稳定性。
患有临床骨关节炎的成年犬
对于已确诊骨关节炎的犬,康复计划的制定以临床评估为指导。患病犬通常表现为姿势或步态异常、触诊疼痛、因关节囊增厚导致的关节活动度降低、肌肉萎缩以及活动能力受损。初始康复目标侧重于通过针对性运动最小化活动期间的疼痛并恢复功能性活动能力(41)。治疗干预措施的选择基于康复评估、主人期望以及支持治疗有效性的现有证据。当活动受限影响日常生活时,也可实施环境改造。
身体健康:关键要点
身体健康是犬骨关节炎管理的核心组成部分。维持体能和活动能力始于基线评估,随后制定针对个体患者和主人的运动方案。规律的日常活动是维护肌肉骨骼健康最有效的策略之一。仔细控制运动强度和持续时间有助于降低症状发作的可能性。
成年犬的营养补充
推荐用于患有骨关节炎的成年犬的饮食和营养补充剂(营养保健品)旨在减轻炎症、改善功能并可能延缓疾病进展(2)。营养补充剂通常具有极好的安全性。与患有骨关节炎的生长发育期犬一样,营养补充剂通常被纳入患有骨关节炎的成年犬的整体健康管理中(2)。
健康成年犬/低骨关节炎风险
骨关节炎发生风险低的成年犬应维持最佳体况。在这些犬中,营养补充剂最常在训练或参与剧烈运动或工作活动的背景下考虑。在这些情况下,补充剂可用于支持肌肉骨骼健康、增强运动能力或可能保护关节免受活动相关应激的影响。
健康成年犬/高骨关节炎风险
具有肌肉骨骼结构异常的的健康成年犬、从事高强度工作或运动的犬以及易早发性骨关节炎品种的犬被认为具有较高的骨关节炎发生风险,特别是因为某些剧烈活动会增加受伤风险。维持最佳体重在这些患者中尤为重要。推荐用于患有骨关节炎的成年犬的补充剂通常与推荐用于患有骨关节炎的生长发育期犬的补充剂相似,包括omega-3脂肪酸、非变性II型胶原蛋白、氨基葡萄糖和软骨素(2)。大多数支持营养补充剂的现有科学证据来自涉及成年犬的研究(3)。
患有临床骨关节炎的成年犬
患有临床骨关节炎的成年犬的营养补充通常包括推荐用于高风险犬的相同补充剂,包括omega-3脂肪酸、非变性II型胶原蛋白、氨基葡萄糖和软骨素(2)。肥胖和慢性肾脏疾病等合并症在患有骨关节炎的成年犬中相对常见。肾脏或胃肠道合并症的存在可能增加与药物性疼痛管理相关的不良事件风险,这可能增加营养补充剂作为非甾体抗炎药(NSAIDs)的辅助或替代方案的吸引力。在一些研究中,营养补充剂与患肢负重增加以及感知到的对NSAIDs等止痛药物需求减少相关(3, 115)。
Omega-3脂肪酸
Omega-3脂肪酸是用于减轻关节炎症的关键营养补充剂。二十碳五烯酸(EPA)促进产生比花生四烯酸分解代谢副产物促炎性更低的类花生酸(2)。来源于海洋的omega-3脂肪酸补充剂通常比短链植物来源(如亚麻籽油)更有效(116)。在一项研究中,含3.5%鱼油来源omega-3脂肪酸的饮食减轻了患有骨关节炎的犬的疼痛和跛行,改善了负重,并减少了对NSAIDs的需求(117)。仅通过补充剂达到相似的omega-3浓度需要大约480 mg/kg的鱼油(50至100 mg/kg EPA),这在某些情况下可能成本高昂且不切实际。绿唇贻贝提取物提供omega-3脂肪酸的替代来源,并且还含有糖胺聚糖和硫酸软骨素。这些提取物热量较低,因为活性化合物更浓缩(118)。绿唇贻贝提取物补充已被证明对患有骨关节炎的犬有益(119),并可能增强NSAIDs的有效性(118)。
非变性II型胶原蛋白(UC-II®)
补充非变性II型胶原蛋白的原理是,持续口服给药可增加对骨关节炎关节中存在的胶原蛋白副产物的免疫耐受性(3)。UC-II是一种源自鸡胸骨的专利非变性II型胶原蛋白形式,已在多项犬类临床研究中证明其安全性和有效性(3)。在一项前瞻性对照临床试验中,补充非变性II型胶原蛋白可减轻健康现场试验犬在剧烈活动后的炎症、软骨分解代谢和酸痛(120, 121)。在患有骨关节炎的犬中,多项研究通过力板步态分析测量,补充非变性II型胶原蛋白与肢体使用方面的客观改善相关(122–125)。在一项比较非变性II型胶原蛋白补充剂与NSAIDs在骨关节炎犬中效果的临床试验中,两种治疗产生了相似的益处(115, 126)。
氨基葡萄糖/软骨素补充剂
氨基葡萄糖和硫酸软骨素(GCS)补充剂是犬最常用的关节补充剂之一。虽然已证明其具有抗炎活性(127),但GCS补充剂在骨关节炎犬中的临床疗效并不一致:一些临床试验报告有改善(128),而另一些则未显示出显著益处(129, 130)。这些混合发现使一些作者得出结论,氨基葡萄糖和软骨素提供的治疗益处有限(3)。
蛋壳膜补充剂
蛋壳膜(ESM)提取物被用作营养补充剂,含有胶原蛋白、氨基葡萄糖、糖胺聚糖、弹性蛋白、透明质酸以及各种氨基酸和蛋白质。许多配方将ESM与虾青素、磷虾油和透明质酸等额外化合物结合。体外研究表明,ESM可能调节炎症通路并可能减少软骨降解。支持蛋壳膜用于骨关节炎管理的科学证据总体上有限。两项在拉布拉多寻回犬中进行的初步研究表明,补充ESM后炎症生物标志物白细胞介素-6(IL-6)浓度降低;然而,LOAD评分并未改善(131, 132)。在一项为期90天的对照临床试验中,补充ESM导致CBPI和LOAD评分改善(133)。
用于管理潜在肌肉量损失的补充
肌肉减少症是指随着年龄增长而发生的肌肉量、质量和力量的逐渐丧失。与恶病质或肌肉减少症相关的肌肉损失涉及肌细胞凋亡增加和再生能力降低(134)。在人类中,肌肉减少症与衰弱、身体残疾风险增加、生活质量降低和死亡率相关(135)。包括IL-6、IL-1β、转化生长因子-β(TGF-β)和肿瘤坏死因子-α(TNF-α)在内的促炎细胞因子促进肌纤维分解(136)。关于患有慢性骨关节炎犬的肌肉减少症的信息有限。在一项对8岁及以上拉布拉多寻回犬的研究中,无炎症介质增加的肌肉减少症是早期死亡的预测因素(137)。临床上,广泛认为骨关节炎相关的肢体废用会导致犬的肌肉萎缩。由于保持肌肉量与维持人类身体功能密切相关(135),支持肌肉量的策略也可能使骨关节炎犬受益。
Fortetropin®是一种非热巴氏杀菌、冻干的受精蛋黄产品,用于支持犬的肌肉量。肌肉生长抑制素是一种属于TGF-β家族的肌因子,通过作用于激活素受体(ACVR2A/B)调节肌肉生长(135)。据信Fortetropin通过降低循环肌肉生长抑制素浓度来促进肌肉生长。多项犬类研究表明肌肉生长抑制素表达与肌肉量之间呈负相关(138)。在一项涉及骨关节炎犬的试验中,在补充6至12周之间观察到LOAD评分改善,尽管与安慰剂的差异无统计学意义(137)。在另一项评估膝关节手术后肌肉萎缩的研究中,接受Fortetropin的犬术后肌肉损失少于对照组(139)。
Ursolyx™含有熊果酸,这是一种植物来源的五环三萜类化合物,具有抗炎、抗氧化、抗癌、抗肥胖和产热特性(136)。在机制上,熊果酸影响骨骼肌细胞中的基因表达,支持参与维持肌肉结构和功能的细胞通路(140)。在犬中,膳食补充熊果酸与骨骼肌量、肌肉质量、力量和耐力增加相关(140)。在一项关于年龄相关肌肉萎缩的研究中,补充熊果酸抑制了50多种与肌肉损失相关的分子标志物,同时激活了与肌肉健康和运动能力相关的标志物(140)。
大麻补充剂
用作补充剂的主要植物大麻素是大麻二酚(CBD)和Δ9-四氢大麻酚(Δ9-THC)。基于CBD在疼痛通路中与一系列参与炎症和镇痛的受体相互作用,CBD很可能在镇痛中发挥作用。在一项研究中,一种CBD产品被安全地用于管理22只犬的OA临床症状(141)。由于在许多司法管辖区,大麻来源化合物被作为药物而非营养补充剂进行监管,因此在推荐、开具或调配大麻营养保健品补充剂之前,应审查当地监管要求。
虽然已发表了多项使用植物大麻素的临床研究(141–145),但没有一项研究使用药用级CBD。因此,关于药用级CBD在犬中的临床安全性和有效性知之甚少。富含CBD的大麻营养保健品在犬中似乎很有前景。在短期研究中,富含CBD的大麻已与非甾体抗炎药(NSAIDs)、泼尼松、阿米替林和加巴喷丁联合使用,未出现任何严重不良事件。这表明药用级CBD可能有益于多模式疼痛管理。富含CBD的大麻也已作为单药使用(141, 142),似乎对管理犬OA疼痛有效。研究之间给药方案的差异可能源于所用产品的差异。在缺乏FDA监管的情况下,富含CBD大麻的有效性和安全性无法得到确认。临床医生可以选择在犬中有阳性临床试验证据的CBD补充剂。
营养补充剂:要点
大多数营养补充剂具有良好的安全性特征。它们在减轻与慢性OA相关的炎性疼痛方面似乎最为有效。一些补充剂可能提供其他疗法未涉及的额外益处,例如改善对胶原降解副产物的耐受性(未变性II型胶原)或支持维持肌肉量(fortetropin、熊果酸)。总体而言,缺乏关于用于犬慢性OA的营养保健品效应大小的信息。在管理人类OA时,氨基葡萄糖-软骨素和未变性II型胶原对缓解OA症状具有轻度至中度效应,一些草药制剂具有较大且具有临床意义的效应(146)。
成年犬OA的药物管理
药物是缓解犬OA疼痛症状最广泛使用的策略,这可能是因为其可预测的疗效、给药便利性、通常可接受的安全性特征以及相对较低的成本。用于管理犬OA的药物属于几个药理学类别。患有OA的成年犬的药物治疗选择见表1。大多数药物通过减轻炎症或调节疼痛相关神经传递发挥作用,尽管一些药物靶向关节结构或软骨代谢,如多硫酸糖胺聚糖。支持这些药物疗效的科学证据强度差异很大。NSAIDs有强有力的证据支持其缓解疼痛和改善功能的能力,而其他药物类别的证据有限或不一致。安全性特征也各不相同。虽然药物不良事件总体上不常见,但其范围可从轻微和短暂的影响(例如单次呕吐发作)到严重并发症,包括危及生命的疾病或死亡(147)。
Table 1. Treatment options, including pharmacologic options, for adult dogs with OA.
| OA stage | Drugs | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Healthy adult dog/low OA risk | None needed | ± Weight and nutritional optimization |
| Healthy adult dog/high OA risk | Likely none needed | Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation |
| Adult dog with clinical OA | Mild pain | NSAIDs Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation |
| Moderate pain | NSAIDs or antiNGF mAbs, if tolerated ± Gabapentinoid or/and NMDA receptor antagonist Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation ± Environmental modifications ± Intraarticular therapy | |
| Severe pain | NSAIDs and/or antiNGF mAbs, if tolerated in the long term Gabapentinoid or/and NMDA receptor antagonist Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation Environmental modifications ± Intraarticular therapy |
非甾体抗炎药
NSAIDs是强效镇痛药,主要通过抑制前列腺素E2(PGE2)的产生来减轻疼痛。几种NSAIDs已获FDA批准用于犬的急性和慢性疼痛管理。由于其在大多数骨关节炎患犬中具有可预测的疗效,NSAIDs被广泛认为是骨关节炎药物治疗的基石(3, 148, 149)。关于NSAIDs在犬中使用的详细综述可在其他文献中查阅(150)。兽医和主人都能观察到大多数接受NSAIDs治疗的犬有所改善。在一项对1,000只接受NSAID治疗40天的犬的研究中,三分之二的犬在14天内改善,四分之三的犬在40天内改善(151)。大多数NSAIDs抑制环氧化酶(COX)-1和COX-2酶。Grapiprant在机制上与传统NSAIDs不同,它选择性抑制前列腺素E2的EP4受体。这种靶向机制可能降低通常与COX抑制相关的不良事件风险,如呕吐、胃肠道溃疡和急性肾损伤(152–155)。Grapiprant治疗骨关节炎患犬有效(153, 156)。在一项临床研究中,grapiprant在管理术后关节疼痛方面比美洛昔康更有效(157)。
抗神经生长因子单克隆抗体(anti-NGF mAbs)
抗神经生长因子单克隆抗体(anti-NGF mAbs)是抑制神经生长因子(NGF)信号传导的镇痛药物。Bedinvetmab是一种抗NGF单克隆抗体,已获FDA批准用于控制犬的骨关节炎疼痛,以每月一次皮下注射的方式给药。抗NGF单克隆抗体的临床效果已在多项研究中描述(4, 158, 159)。其在骨关节炎患犬中的镇痛疗效似乎与NSAIDs相当(160)。抗NGF单克隆抗体的安全性特征与NSAIDs不同。不良事件总体上似乎不常见(160),但有报道描述在某些病例中出现神经系统疾病加重和关节退行性病变进展(161–163)。已描述了几种可能不同的关节退行性病变模式,包括关节退行性病变快速进展、非典型关节周围骨重塑以及广泛的异位关节周围矿化,该过程也被称为隐匿性抗神经生长因子诱导的关节周围矿化(163–165)。
多硫酸糖胺聚糖
多硫酸糖胺聚糖(PSGAGs)是可能影响软骨代谢和炎症的疾病修饰药物。一种PSGAG(Adequan)已获FDA批准用于治疗犬的骨关节炎,以每周两次、共8次肌肉注射的疗程给药。PSGAGs的有益作用可能部分通过减少关节内炎症介质来介导。在一项关键研究中,2至10月龄接受PSGAG治疗的髋关节发育不良生长犬与未治疗的对照犬相比,软骨损伤更少,关节松弛度更低(166)。与PSGAG相关的化合物,如戊聚糖多硫酸酯,已在美国以外地区用于骨关节炎管理。除NSAIDs、抗NGF单克隆抗体和PSGAG外,支持其他用于管理犬骨关节炎疼痛的药物类别的证据要有限得多(4)。
加巴喷丁和普瑞巴林
加巴喷丁类药物与突触前电压门控钙通道的α2δ-1亚基结合,减少兴奋性神经递质的释放。这些药物主要用于缓解神经病理性疼痛。加巴喷丁和普瑞巴林通常需要每日给药两到三次以维持治疗效果。不良反应可能包括一过性镇静和共济失调。常用建议剂量为加巴喷丁10至20 mg/kg每8小时一次(167),普瑞巴林4 mg/kg每12小时一次(168, 169)。犬的最佳剂量仍不确定,这可能导致临床实践中剂量不足。加巴喷丁常作为犬慢性疼痛多模式疼痛管理策略的一部分使用;然而,支持其治疗骨关节炎相关疼痛疗效的证据有限(128)。
金刚烷胺和氯胺酮
金刚烷胺和氯胺酮是在中枢神经系统内起作用的N-甲基-D-天冬氨酸(NMDA)受体拮抗剂。通过抑制脊髓中的NMDA受体活性,NMDA受体拮抗可能有助于预防或逆转中枢敏化(“疼痛上扬”),尽管它们可能不提供直接镇痛效果。在一项临床试验中,每日一次金刚烷胺联合NSAID给药提高了骨关节炎患犬的活动水平(170)。每日两次给药可能比每日一次给药提供更大获益(4, 167)。氯胺酮有时被经验性地用于管理慢性疼痛,以0.5 mg/kg间歇性皮下给药,或静脉持续速率输注,通常约为10 μg/kg/min,持续4小时或更长时间。
阿片类药物
阿片类药物不常用于犬慢性骨关节炎疼痛的长期管理,并且与其他镇痛药物类别相比,在控制慢性疼痛方面通常效果较差。然而,它们可能有助于管理严重疼痛或爆发性疼痛。阿片类药物受到严格管制,并常产生不良反应,包括镇静、恶心和便秘。增加膳食纤维可能有助于缓解长期接受阿片类药物治疗犬的便秘。口服阿片类药物在犬中的疗效似乎有限,可能是由于口服生物利用度相对较差(167)。
曲马多
曲马多是一种具有阿片样镇痛作用,并附加5-羟色胺能和去甲肾上腺素能活性的镇痛药。在犬中,其镇痛效应被认为主要源于对去甲肾上腺素再摄取的抑制,而非经典阿片受体激活。犬缺乏将曲马多充分代谢转化为其阿片活性代谢物(O-去甲基曲马多,M1)的能力,因此曲马多产生的μ-阿片受体介导的镇痛效应可忽略不计(171)。单独使用时,曲马多似乎不能为犬OA疼痛提供有意义的缓解(117)。然而,一些研究提示曲马多与NSAIDs联合使用时可能提供额外获益(172)。
抗抑郁药
三环类抗抑郁药如阿米替林已被考虑用于慢性疼痛的管理(169)。5-羟色胺-去甲肾上腺素再摄取抑制剂(SNRIs),包括度洛西汀、文拉法辛、去甲文拉法辛和米那普仑,在人医中用于治疗慢性疼痛。然而,目前缺乏关于其在患有OA的犬中的疗效或安全性的信息。
利多卡因
利多卡因偶尔以恒速输注的方式用于剧烈疼痛的犬。在人医中,围手术期利多卡因输注可降低慢性疼痛发生的风险(173),并减少阿片类药物的需求量(174)。
糖皮质激素(皮质类固醇)
糖皮质激素是强效抗炎药,但与显著的全身性不良反应相关,尤其是在长期给药时(150)。因此,全身性糖皮质激素用于犬慢性OA管理已变得不常见。
关节内注射
与人和马不同(175, 176),使用关节内(IA)注射管理犬OA相对不常见(177)。IA注射包括皮质类固醇、透明质酸、富血小板血浆、自体干细胞、骨髓抽吸浓缩物、基质血管组分、聚丙烯酰胺水凝胶(PAAG)和放射性锡(锡-117m放射性滑膜切除术)。犬的IA注射最常在镇静下进行。需要剃毛并对注射部位进行无菌准备。IA注射总体上似乎是安全的。并发症包括疼痛和跛行的暂时性加重以及脓毒性关节炎。在一份评估对IA注射各种产品反应报告中,五分之一的犬(18.4%)在IA后表现出疼痛迹象,中位疼痛持续时间为2天(178)。在该报告中,疼痛主要与干细胞注射相关。
皮质类固醇
皮质类固醇具有强大的抗炎作用(150)。醋酸甲泼尼龙(每关节最多20 mg)和曲安奈德(每关节1至3 mg)在犬中最常用。典型的疼痛缓解在12至24小时后可见,并可持续长达6个月(179)。多尿、多饮或多食等副作用不常见。然而,皮质类固醇似乎对软骨和滑膜产生负面影响,即使在单次暴露后也是如此(180)。这些不良反应在曲安奈德暴露后可能不存在(181)。
透明质酸(HA)
HA(透明质酸钠、透明质烷)是一种普遍存在的糖胺聚糖分子,存在于所有生物体中。HA与软骨细胞上的CD44受体结合,诱导细胞增殖和细胞外基质产生,刺激滑膜细胞合成透明质烷(一种内源性糖胺聚糖),抑制炎症介质,并对软骨细胞发挥抗凋亡作用(182)。关节内HA旨在恢复关节液的物理特性以帮助关节润滑、减少炎症和降解,并有助于软骨修复(183)。有几种HA制剂可用于关节内注射。推荐使用高分子量HA,因为它更接近天然存在的HA。在一项比较高分子量HA与干细胞疗法的试验中,HA似乎比干细胞疗法更有效(184)。然而,IA HA的临床获益总体上似乎有限,且IA HA最常与其他产品联合使用。
水凝胶
几种水凝胶在临床上用于管理犬OA。胶原弹性蛋白水凝胶微粒(CEHM)由胶原、弹性蛋白和肝素的纯化自组装组合物制成。记录CEHM疗效的同行评审信息有限。在一项试验中,患有OA的犬对CEHM和曲安奈德的临床反应与单独使用曲安奈德的反应无差异(185)。聚丙烯酰胺水凝胶提供黏性补充并作为关节润滑剂。聚丙烯酰胺水凝胶有几种浓度可供使用:2.5%聚丙烯酰胺似乎被整合到滑膜中,而4%则与软骨结合(186, 187)。2.5%聚丙烯酰胺浓度在人和马OA患者中似乎安全有效(188, 189)。在一项犬主人调查中(100只犬,150个注射关节),10%的主人报告了轻微且自限性的不良事件,82%的主人认为其犬有所改善(190)。
再生医学
再生医学产品(骨科生物制剂)包括血液来源和脂肪来源的产品。血液来源产品包括富血小板血浆(PRP)、自体条件血清(ACS)或血浆(ACP)、骨髓抽吸物及骨髓抽吸浓缩物(BMAC)。脂肪来源产品包括从脂肪组织获得的基质血管组分(SVF),可直接使用或经培养扩增后使用。在美国,FDA将骨科生物制剂归类为药物(191)。犬最常用的骨科生物制剂为自体(患者来源)产品。单独使用PRP或与HA联合使用似乎是最广泛应用的骨科生物制剂产品(192)。脂肪或骨髓干细胞已用于患有OA的犬,总体上似乎有益(193)。同种异体骨科生物制剂治疗正在兴起,但目前缺乏其疗效证据(194)。
放射性核素锡-117m
放射性锡-117m已获FDA批准用于管理犬肘关节滑膜炎。锡放射性核素释放低能电子,促进炎症滑膜细胞坏死。放射性锡-117m的临床安全性和疗效已在小样本病例系列中评估(195–197),该治疗总体上似乎是安全的(198)。
对于所有注入关节的化合物,应考虑潜在的细胞毒性(即软骨毒性)。几种局部麻醉药(利多卡因、布比卡因、罗哌卡因)和皮质类固醇(曲安奈德)具有软骨毒性(199)。当化合物与透明质酸联合注射时,软骨毒性似乎可被减轻。关于PRP软骨毒性的信息尚缺乏(199)。在一项对174名从业者的调查中,94%的受访者使用IA治疗(200)。肘关节是最常注射的关节。富血小板血浆和黏性补充剂是最常注射的产品。
药物管理:关键要点
NSAIDs仍是犬OA药物管理的基石。几种辅助药物可能提供额外益处,且通常具有可接受的安全性特征,尽管其疗效不如NSAIDs稳定。可用的注射疗法日益增多,可能提供短期临床改善,但关于其长期有效性的证据仍然有限。
成年犬OA管理的手术干预
对受OA影响的关节,手术可以治疗为目的或以挽救性手术为目的进行。治疗性手术旨在解决关节疾病的潜在病因,可能包括移除关节内骨软骨碎片、改善关节一致性或稳定性,或用移植软骨替换受损软骨。挽救性手术包括切除、置换或融合受影响的关节。
髋关节
髋关节发育不良是髋关节OA最常见的原因(201),并且可能是犬最常见的骨科疾病。其他可能导致髋关节OA的疾病包括Legg-Calvé-Perthes病和涉及股骨头生长板的骨折(202)。在患有髋关节发育不良的犬中,OA通常在整个生命周期中逐渐进展(8, 203),超重会加速疾病进展(203)。旨在改善髋关节稳定性的手术包括幼年耻骨联合固定术(通常在约16周龄时进行)和双骨盆截骨术(通常在约6月龄时进行)。晚期疾病的挽救性手术包括股骨头和颈切除术及全髋关节置换术(204)。支持早期治疗性手术预防OA进展的长期疗效的证据有限。相比之下,全髋关节置换术与良好的长期结局相关,但手术复杂且费用高昂。
膝关节
在膝关节中,颅交叉韧带变性或断裂(CCLR)和髌骨脱位是OA最常见的原因(11)。由于与保守管理相比,手术治疗后主人满意度往往更高(205),CCLR通常采用手术治疗。常见的手术包括胫骨截骨技术和使用假体材料的关节囊外稳定术。总体而言,截骨手术后的结局似乎略优于关节囊外稳定术(206)。髌骨脱位也经常进行手术矫正(207)。手术目标是恢复髌骨在滑车沟内的正常轨迹,并重新对齐膝关节的伸肌机制(即股四头肌、髌骨和髌韧带)。手术技术根据对线不良的严重程度选择,可能包括滑车加深术、胫骨结节移位术和软组织叠瓦术(207)。手术治疗通常成功率高。然而,由于评估手术矫正后OA进展的长期研究有限,髌骨稳定后OA是否继续进展仍不清楚。
跗关节
与髋关节和肘关节相比,跗关节OA不常见。它最常继发于距骨剥脱性骨软骨炎、关节内骨折或创伤性脱位。严重的跗关节OA通常采用关节融合术管理。全踝关节置换术和定制外假体在犬中很少使用(208)。
肩关节
肩关节骨关节炎相对常见(209),尽管其潜在病因往往不明确。肱骨头剥脱性骨软骨炎是部分犬发生骨关节炎的原因(202)。据报道,肩部损伤也是参加敏捷性训练的犬中最常见的肌肉骨骼损伤(210)。这些损伤可能导致关节不稳定,严重时可导致脱位。对于有明显肩关节不稳定的犬,可进行手术稳定(211)。在严重或慢性不稳定的病例中,可考虑将肩关节融合术作为挽救性手术。
肘关节
肘关节骨关节炎常见,最常继发于肘关节发育不良(202),后者通常累及关节内侧间室(19)。针对肘关节发育不良的手术包括关节镜或开放手术移除骨软骨碎片、关节面重建手术以及尺骨或肱骨截骨术。然而,支持这些手术疗效的科学证据有限(212)。全肘关节置换术在犬中很少实施(213)。
腕关节
腕关节骨关节炎不常见。它可能继发于过度伸展损伤、关节内骨折或免疫介导性疾病。严重不稳定和晚期腕关节骨关节炎最常采用腕关节融合术治疗。
骨关节炎的手术治疗:要点
骨关节炎最常累及犬的髋关节和肘关节,主要由于髋关节和肘关节发育不良的高患病率。在疾病早期,可实施多种手术以解决潜在病因或可能延缓骨关节炎进展,尽管支持这些干预措施长期疗效的证据有限。
整合所有方法管理成年犬骨关节炎
流行病学调查提示,约四分之一的成年犬患有骨关节炎。临床表现差异很大,从无可检测的异常到严重残疾不等。然而,许多患病犬经历持续的关节炎症和疼痛。因此,有效管理的目标是尽量减少骨关节炎当前的影响、延缓疾病进展并优化犬的整体生活质量。骨关节炎的生理影响主要是关节炎症,可通过药物、适当的营养和营养补充剂进行管理。骨关节炎的身体后果包括疼痛以及力量和体能可能下降。这些通过疼痛管理、体育活动、治疗性运动和体重优化来处理。骨关节炎的功能影响通常表现为推进力减弱、活动能力下降和耐力减退,可通过生活方式调整和人体工学支持来改善。
治疗计划应个体化,并受骨关节炎的严重程度和慢性程度以及患者和主人因素的影响(74)。尽管有广泛的治疗选择,但对许多主人而言,实施所有可能的干预措施并不可行。这凸显了兽医在为特定患者和情况考虑治疗方案时为主人提供咨询的重要性。考虑主人的目标和优先事项很重要,并应尽可能简化治疗。在费用、时间、精力和风险方面尽量减少治疗负担,可能有助于鼓励主人为其犬寻求骨关节炎治疗。
在大多数情况下,骨关节炎最初采用保守治疗而非手术。保守管理的核心组成部分包括优化营养和营养补充剂、镇痛药物、适当的体育活动和生活方式调整。这些方法可提供有意义的短期缓解,也可能有助于长期关节健康。药物治疗通常以口服药物开始,最常见的是NSAIDs(如果耐受良好)。单独使用NSAIDs似乎足以改善超过半数骨关节炎犬的关节疼痛和功能(151)。当对NSAIDs反应不完全时,通常考虑替代疗法如抗NGF单克隆抗体和/或辅助口服药物,随后考虑关节内药物。当犬仅通过体重优化、营养补充剂、生活方式调整和药物治疗无法得到充分管理时,也可考虑其他管理策略。这些辅助选项包括电物理疗法、手法治疗、治疗性运动计划和人体工学支持。
在可用的干预措施中,维持最佳体况对于长期预防骨关节炎进展具有最强的证据支持(5, 6)。证据也支持规律体育活动和肌内注射多硫酸糖胺聚糖在延缓疾病进展方面的益处(166, 214)。然而,由于成年犬的骨关节炎在诊断时往往已存在很长时间,一旦关节结构改变已充分建立,旨在长期保护关节的干预措施可能效果较差。
与主人的持续沟通对于有效的OA管理至关重要。标准评估工具,如CBPI和LOAD问卷,有助于量化基线疾病影响、监测治疗反应并检测疾病进展。由于许多治疗干预措施,特别是镇痛药物,应能使患有OA相关疼痛的犬获得相对快速的改善,因此初次随访应在开始治疗后几天内进行。该随访有助于确保主人理解治疗计划、治疗有效且安全,并且在未来数月内切实可行地维持。如果临床症状得到充分控制,大约3个月后重新评估可能是合适的。如果症状仍然控制不佳,则需要更早重新评估。治疗反应不充分的常见原因包括持续性炎症、慢性适应性不良性疼痛和体能下降。持续性疼痛可能需要调整镇痛治疗或增加电物理疗法或手法治疗。体能下降可通过有针对性的治疗性运动(包括水疗(76))和额外的人体工学支持来解决。定期重新评估,通常每季度一次,有助于确保随着疾病进展管理仍然有效。
总之,OA在成年犬中常见。其管理复杂,但可通过结合旨在维持理想体况的优化营养、适当的营养补充和有效的疼痛控制来简化。NSAIDs仍然是管理OA相关疼痛和炎症方面最具可预测疗效的药物。体育活动有益,应仔细调整以尽量减少症状发作。与主人的持续沟通和定期重新评估对于维持患病犬OA的有效长期管理至关重要。
致谢
作者感谢纽约州伊萨卡市康奈尔大学的Joseph J. Wakshlag博士在稿件准备过程中提供的意见。
资助声明
作者声明本研究及/或其发表未获得财务支持。
脚注
[内容请查看原文]
作者贡献
DM-L:监督、写作——审阅与编辑、项目管理、概念化、写作——原稿。JH:写作——审阅与编辑、写作——原稿。TG:写作——审阅与编辑、写作——原稿。APM:写作——审阅与编辑、写作——原稿。MB:写作——原稿、写作——审阅与编辑。DH:写作——原稿、写作——审阅与编辑。BF:写作——审阅与编辑、概念化、数据管理、写作——原稿、项目管理。
利益冲突
BF受雇于Vetoquinol USA。
其余作者声明本研究的开展不存在任何可能被视为潜在利益冲突的商业或财务关系。
生成式AI声明
作者声明本手稿的创作中未使用生成式AI。
本文图中提供的任何替代文本(alt text)均由Frontiers在人工智能支持下生成,并已尽合理努力确保准确性,包括在可能情况下由作者审阅。如果您发现任何问题,请联系我们。
出版商注
本文中表达的所有主张仅代表作者本人,不一定代表其所属组织,也不一定代表出版商、编辑和审稿人的观点。本文中可能评估的任何产品或其制造商可能提出的任何主张均不受出版商的保证或认可。
参考文献
[内容请查看原文]
查看英文原文▾
Abstract
Osteoarthritis (OA) affects nearly half of adult dogs and has physiological, physical, and functional consequences. The physiological impact of OA includes joint inflammation, progressive cartilage degeneration, and pain. Physically, OA changes commonly result in reduced limb strength, muscle atrophy, and, in some cases, decreased joint range of motion. Functionally, OA manifests as diminished willingness or ability to climb stairs, jump, play, exercise, or perform routine activities. These functional losses negatively impact quality of life for both dogs and their caregivers. Effective OA management requires a comprehensive and multimodal approach. Therapeutic options include nutrition, nutritional supplementation, medications, lifestyle changes, electrophysical modalities, manual therapy, therapeutic exercise, ergonomic support, and surgery. Because OA is a chronic and progressive condition, management strategies must be practical, individualized, and sustainable over the long term. Protocols should be streamlined to minimize caregiver burden while maximizing clinical benefit. Foundational management includes nutritional strategies to optimize metabolic health and maintain ideal body condition. Nutritional supplements may provide safe and practical adjunctive support to decrease joint inflammation and pain. When joint pain is identified, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs remain a predictably effective first-line pharmacologic therapy. Additional or alternative therapeutic interventions should be added when initial therapy is inadequate or when safety considerations limit use. Sustained and structured client communication is critical to setting expectations, monitoring response to therapy, and adapting management plans over time. Successful OA management depends not only on therapeutic selection but also on long-term adherence, reassessment, and individualized adjustment. A consensus-driven, multimodal framework provides clinicians with a practical and sustainable strategy to optimize outcomes for adult dogs with OA.
Keywords: dog, osteoarthritis, treatment guidelines, weight management, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, nutritional supplements, nutraceuticals, physical rehabilitation
Introduction
Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common chronic orthopedic condition in dogs. It typically results from developmental orthopedic diseases, most commonly hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, and patellar luxation (1). OA may also develop as a consequence of acquired conditions, most commonly cranial cruciate ligament injury (1). Less frequently, OA may develop from other developmental orthopedic diseases (osteochondritis dissecans, angular limb deformities, developmental joint instability), trauma (e.g., articular fractures), and systemic diseases affecting joints (e.g., immune-mediated joint disease, von Willebrand disease). OA develops more rapidly in larger dogs and in dogs with excess body weight. Although OA often develops early in life and may be detected and managed in growing dogs (2), it is more frequently diagnosed and managed in adulthood. While OA and pain management in dogs have been extensively reviewed (3, 4), limited attention has been given to how life stages influence management decisions. This article is the second in a series of articles reviewing the management of OA across life stages. The previous article reviewed OA management in growing dogs (2). This article reviews the current literature and discusses OA management considerations in adult dogs. Recommendations are provided for healthy dogs at low and high risk of OA as well as dogs with clinical OA. Healthy adult dogs without underlying musculoskeletal conformational abnormalities, that are not engaged in high-intensity work or sport, and that do not belong to breeds predisposed to early-onset OA are considered at lower risk for developing OA. Because the present article references the first article in the series (2), review of that article is recommended prior to reading this manuscript.
OA pathophysiology
OA is generally progressive; over time new clinical signs develop and existing signs gradually increase in severity and duration (5, 6). The primary consequences of OA are local physiologic changes that negatively affect joint surfaces, the joint capsule, and the subchondral bone. Articular surfaces undergo degeneration, including fibrillation and abrasion. Focal full-thickness cartilage erosion is common on the femoral head and dorsal acetabular rim of the dysplastic hip and on the medial coronoid process and medial aspect of the humeral condyle of the dysplastic elbow. The joint capsule undergoes fibrotic thickening. Osteophytes form at the margins of the articular surfaces and enthesophytes develop at intra-articular insertion sites. Inflammation persists in the joint capsule and subchondral bone (7). The extent of articular surface damage, capsular fibrosis, osteophytic proliferation, and subchondral inflammation varies widely among dogs, even within a single orthopedic condition (8–11). For example, with hip dysplasia large osteophytes develop in some joints but not others (9). Osteophyte formation in the dysplastic hip progresses more rapidly in younger dogs and in spayed females (8). Loss of joint motion secondary to capsular fibrosis and potential periarticular adhesions also varies widely (9). Severe restriction of joint motion in joints with OA may result in markedly compromised limb use and gait. The severity of inflammation associated with OA likely contributes substantially to persistent pain and disability (10).
Subjectively, adult dogs with OA often present for care with specific profiles: limb disuse associated with severe inflammation or functional decline secondary to chronic pain, muscle atrophy, and reduced joint motion. Dogs with severe inflammation are often young adults. In these cases, inflammation may persist from early disease or be triggered by excessive activity, a phenomenon described as “weekend warrior syndrome,” in which generally inactive dogs engage in strenuous exercise and subsequently exhibit OA signs. Dogs with progressive loss of function and impaired limb use are more often middle-aged to older adults. Their signs develop gradually. Their owners commonly describe them as less happy and less active. Estimating the relative contributions of inflammation, chronic pain, muscle atrophy, and reduced joint motion in an adult dog with OA can guide selection of the most appropriate management strategies. Although dogs and humans share many similarities in OA (12), structural changes are often more pronounced and progression more rapid in dogs than humans (13, 14). These differences should be considered when extrapolating evidence from human OA management.
The clinical expression of pain in canine OA also varies widely, ranging from subtle signs (minor weight shifts, mild or intermittent lameness) to severe, debilitating pain (limb disuse, non-weight bearing lameness) (9). Variability in pain expression has been attributed to local nociceptive amplification and central sensitization, as well as to neuropathic and psychogenic pain components. Less is known in dogs than humans regarding the relative contribution of these various mechanisms (15). In the absence of definitive information about the roles of nociceptive, neuropathic, and psychogenic pain, clinicians should rely on careful clinical assessment. Severe clinical signs suggest the involvement of at least one or more of these pain mechanisms and warrant comprehensive, multimodal pain management.
Diagnosis of OA
Because the impact of OA varies widely among dogs, both with each cause of OA and across various causes of OA, it is critical to establish a physical and functional baseline at the time of initial presentation. Detection of OA is often prompted by owner concerns regarding gait or mobility, but it may also result from orthopedic screening, particularly in dogs intended for breeding, sport, or work. In some cases, OA is identified incidentally, such as when hip OA is noted on abdominal radiographs.
A baseline diagnosis of OA should identify the affected joint or joints and characterize the severity of the problem in each affected joint. Assessment of severity includes the evaluation of pain (response to palpation, limb disuse), physical changes (loss of joint motion, muscle atrophy), and functional impairment (reduced willingness to walk, play, or perform routine activities). Accordingly, diagnosis should include a thorough orthopedic examination to estimate pain severity and structural change, along with at least one validated owner questionnaire (16) to assess functional impact. Several validated instruments are available, including the Canine Brief Pain Inventory (CBPI, 2007), the Helsinki Chronic Pain Index (HCPI, 2009), the Liverpool Osteoarthritis in Dogs score (LOAD, 2009), and the Canine Orthopedic Index (COI, 2014) (16). Minimal clinically important differences have been reported for the COI (14 points) and LOAD (4 points) (17). The CBPI appears to be the most widely used client-reported outcome measure. Incorporating a questionnaire is particularly important because fewer than half of dogs with OA exhibit lameness readily recognized by owners (14, 18).
While the orthopedic examination may raise strong suspicion for OA, confirmation typically requires diagnostic imaging, as in growing dogs (2). Radiography is most often used to confirm OA based on the identification of osteophytes and enthesophytes (8). Computed tomography (CT) scans may be indicated when superimposition limits radiographic sensitivity, particularly in the elbow joint, where radiographs have limited sensitivity for detection of fragmentation of the medial coronoid process (2). CT may also be useful in the tarsus, carpus, and other complex joints and can be used to quantify OA severity (19). Overall, the correlation between imaging findings and clinical severity is weak. In one study of dogs with elbow OA, the correlation between clinically detectable pain and radiographic OA severity was poor, whereas correlation between pain and tissue inflammation identified using positron emission tomography scanning was stronger (10). Arthroscopy can also be used to diagnose OA and can combine the diagnostic evaluation with a therapeutic intervention. For example, elbow arthroscopy can confirm OA and allow for removal of a fragmented medial coronoid process. Small diameter (needle) scopes reduce invasiveness (20), although their capacity for concurrent treatment is more limited than that of conventional rigid arthroscopes. Accurate diagnosis is particularly important in sporting and working dogs, in whom OA-associated pain may adversely affect training and performance. Regular screening using owner questionnaires, observation, and palpation may increase the likelihood of early detection in these populations.
In summary, OA may be identified through owner concern, screening questionnaires, clinical examination, or incidental imaging findings. The severity of clinical signs does not consistently correlate with the severity of structural changes on imaging but may more closely reflect the degree of tissue inflammation within and surrounding the affected joint.
Whole body wellness in adult dogs with OA
Client education regarding the signs of OA pain and the anticipated progression of disease is fundamental to successful long-term management. Clients should understand that, as OA progresses, clinical signs may include joint swelling, pain on palpation, decreased range of motion, stiffness, muscle atrophy, reduced limb use, and diminished mobility. Functional changes such as difficulty climbing stairs, limping, trouble rising, or inability to jump are also commonly associated with OA pain in adult dogs. Painful dogs may withdraw from interaction or respond with irritability or aggression when touched. These behavioral changes can complicate OA management and can strain relationships within the household.
As mobility declines, environmental challenges within the home become increasingly relevant. For example, a dog may struggle to climb steep stairs or navigate slippery floors. Although these challenges are often associated with geriatric dogs, they frequently begin in middle-aged adults. Recommending environmental modifications, such as rugs, mats, or carpet runners, may help improve traction and safety. Elevating food and water dishes can enhance comfort, and ramps may facilitate access more effectively than steps.
Whole body wellness supports both quality of life and long-term disease control. It encompasses intentional attention to lifestyle structure, nutrition, and exercise. Establishing a consistent daily routine can improve compliance and minimize fear, frustration, and anxiety. Baseline functional information should be collected early so that owners can identify and report meaningful changes in mobility, activity level, or demeanor that may indicate disease progression or a flare-up.
A collaborative relationship between the owner and the veterinary advisor is essential. Management decisions should reflect the owner's desired level of involvement, willingness to pursue therapies supported by varying levels of evidence, financial considerations, and preferences regarding home-based vs. clinic-delivered care. Clear, ongoing communication between the owner and patient care management team facilitates timely adjustment of management strategies and supports sustainable long-term care.
A nutritional plan should support maintenance of a lean body condition. If the dog is overweight, structured guidance, including dietary recommendations, caloric targets, and appropriate weight loss rates, should be provided to the dog owner. Nutritional supplementation may be discussed and implemented based on individual patient needs.
Exercise and play should be incorporated into the dog's daily routine, as greater activity levels are associated with fewer clinical signs of lameness (9). Activity should be individualized for both the dog and the owner. Dogs should be conditioned gradually, and owners should be trained to recognize signs of fatigue or pain. Intensity, frequency, and duration of exercise should be defined, with structured plans to improve strength and endurance when appropriate. A proactive plan should be established to modify activity type, intensity, or duration in the event of an OA flare or when increased clinical signs are consistently associated with specific exercises or workloads. Dogs should also be trained to engage in appropriate behaviors, avoiding lead pulling and other counterproductive patterns, as lead pulling appears to negatively affect the quality, duration, and frequency of walks (21). For sporting and working dogs, whole body wellness includes balancing training and performance demands with recovery. Rest must be intentionally incorporated into training schedules to prevent overuse injuries and chronic stress.
Whole body wellness: key points
Whole body wellness is fundamental to managing OA in adult dogs. A consistent and appropriately modified lifestyle, optimized nutrition, structured exercise, and balanced work or sport participation help to maintain strength and fitness, reduce the likelihood of OA flares, and support sustained control of OA over time.
Physical wellness in adult dogs with OA
Body condition
Fitness refers to a dog's ability to perform functional activities efficiently and effectively. It encompasses cardiovascular and respiratory health, musculoskeletal strength, endurance, and agility. Fit dogs are expected to demonstrate greater mobility and flexibility, improved overall cardiovascular fitness, improved exercise recovery, and reduced risk of chronic diseases. Optimizing fitness promotes healthspan—the period of life spent in good health, free from chronic disease and disability (22, 23).
Aging is commonly associated with musculoskeletal change, including loss of muscle mass and generalized sarcopenia (23). Fatness (adiposity) refers to the proportion of body fat relative to lean body mass. Ideal body condition corresponds to a body condition score (BCS) of 4 or 5 out of 9 (24). Overweight dogs (BCS 6/9) carry excess adipose tissue, and obese dogs (BCS ≥ 7/9) typically exceed ideal body weight by 20% or more. Excess adiposity negatively affects overall health: overweight dogs are at an increased risk for systemic illnesses such as diabetes, cardiac disease, and OA, and have a shorter life expectancy (6, 25). They also have decreased stamina and increased susceptibility to overheating (26). As dogs age, their body fat percentage generally increases, although weight loss may be observed in very old dogs (23, 27). Fitness and fatness are inversely correlated, although a dog may be overweight yet physically conditioned or lean yet poorly conditioned. Many dogs are overweight or obese (28, 29), and owners frequently underestimate their dog's body condition; more than one-third of owners may not accurately assess BCS (28, 30). Sporting and working dogs are expected to have higher fitness levels than sedentary dogs due to structured training. In one study, mean body fat percentage was lower in sporting dogs (13.8 ± 5.3%) than in non-sporting dogs (19.1 ± 8.6%) (30). Excess body weight is clinically significant in the management of OA as it exacerbates systemic inflammation and the signs of OA in dogs (25, 31, 32).
Neutering increases the risk of weight gain (2) even when performed in adulthood (33), and is associated with an increased risk of certain orthopedic conditions, including hip and elbow dysplasia and cranial cruciate ligament injury (34–36). In one study, OA progression was more rapid in spayed females, possibly related to estrogen deficiency (8). When a dog has an ideal body condition, a collaborative nutrition plan should be implemented to maintain it. For overweight dogs, structured support should include calculation of daily energy requirements, dietary recommendations (including foods to avoid), a target weight, and a safe rate of weight loss. Nutritional supplementation should be discussed and implemented based on specific patient needs.
Canine obesity is a complex metabolic disease often present in dogs with OA. Successful weight loss regimens require a controlled negative energy balance, while preserving lean body mass (LBM) and preventing nutritional deficiencies. Therapeutic diets require an elevated protein-to-calorie ratio. Clinical guidelines recommend > 30 to 40% protein dry matter (DM) or > 85 g of protein per 1,000 kcal to support muscle maintenance during lipolysis. Restricting fat (typically to 8 to 12% DM) is the primary method for reducing overall caloric density in dog food. However, formulations must still provide adequate essential fatty acids (e.g., linoleic acid) to maintain epidermal barrier function (37). Elevated fiber (typically, 10 to 15% DM or more) dilutes energy density and promotes satiety via gastric distension and delayed emptying, which experimentally shows efficacy. However, clinically it may not provide the gastric fill required for long-term satiety. An optimal diet uses a blend of primarily insoluble fiber for bulking and lesser soluble fiber for glycemic and microbiome support (37). Restricting standard diets for weight loss is not recommended, as it risks micronutrient deficiencies. Therefore, purpose-formulated therapeutic diets are optimal, providing an elevated nutrient-to-calorie ratio to ensure 100% daily requirements for vitamins and minerals, despite caloric restriction. Many of these diets contain higher protein to preserve lean body mass (LBM) during weight loss. Also, omega-3 fatty acids can be added with the intent to modulate inflammation and support joint health. However, omega-3 concentration in many weight-loss diets is not sufficient to alleviate the inflammation associated with OA. For optimal outcomes, practitioners should calculate daily caloric targets using the patient's ideal body weight (IBW). For a weight-loss program, the calories fed to dogs is based on resting energy requirement (RER) using the formula: RER = 70 x (IBW kg)0.75. Weight-loss programs often start by feeding 80% of the RER corresponding to the IBW. Bi-weekly to monthly monitoring of body weight and BCS is crucial to titrate intake and ensure a safe 1 to 2% weekly weight loss. Weight maintenance programs for obesity-prone dogs should also include moderately high protein intake to preserve LBM and support a healthy basal metabolic rate. Dogs in weight maintenance programs should be fed at RER for the ideal body weight (37).
Activity and exercise
Body composition and physical activity are closely interconnected and together influence musculoskeletal health and the clinical expression of OA in dogs. Historically, activity restriction was commonly recommended for adult dogs with OA, in part because transient increases in lameness may occur following exercise (38). However, over the long term, greater activity levels are associated with fewer clinical signs of lameness in dogs with OA (9). Similarly, exercise decreases pain and improves function in humans with knee OA (39). Exercise and play should therefore be incorporated into the dog's daily routine. Activities must be adapted to the individual patient and owner. Dogs should be trained to engage in appropriate exercise behaviors, avoiding lead pulling and other patterns that reduce comfort, safety, and effectiveness of activity (21). Baseline intensity, frequency, and duration of exercise should be established, with structured plans to improve strength or endurance when appropriate.
Exercise programs should align with the dog's functional goals, whether maintaining general fitness, engaging in recreational play, or preparing for sport or work. Owners and trainers should remain mindful of risks associated with specific activities. For example, in one study, daily hikes or runs were associated with an increased risk of cranial cruciate ligament injury in agility dogs (40). Signs of fatigue or discomfort must be recognized and addressed. A proactive plan should be developed to modify activity type, duration, or intensity during symptom flares or when increased clinical signs are consistently associated with specific workloads.
Physical rehabilitation
In adult dogs with OA undergoing physical rehabilitation, the management plan should consider both patient and owner factors. Patient factors include age, size, temperament, training status, severity of pain and disability, and the presence of comorbidities or risk factors for symptom flares. Owner factors include goals, experience, motivation, available time, financial resources, physical ability to assist with exercises, and other practical limitations that may affect adherence to the rehabilitation plan. Rehabilitation plans consider the type, frequency, intensity, and duration of activity. Dogs with greater risk factors or more severe clinical presentations generally require a more progressive and multifaceted management program (41). Expected outcomes differ between pet dogs and working dogs. Pet dogs should ideally be comfortable during routine daily activities and play. In contrast, working dogs are expected to perform their occupational or sporting activities without functional limitations.
Pain must be minimized before initiating or intensifying an exercise program. The simplest approach capable of achieving adequate pain control is generally preferred. In some dogs, pain can be managed with medication alone. In others, effective pain control may require a combination of pharmacologic therapy, nutritional supplementation, electrophysical modalities, or manual therapy. Once pain is adequately controlled, therapeutic exercise becomes a central component of OA management. Exercise intensity and duration are gradually increased as the dog progresses toward treatment goals. Periods of rest between activities should be tailored to prevent fatigue, declines in performance, or recurrence of clinical signs. Over time, management plans often become simpler and rely increasingly on owner-delivered care, such as home exercise programs and routine activities that maintain fitness while avoiding symptom flares.
Patient assessment
Patient assessment is essential for developing individualized treatment goals, creating an OA management plan, and selecting outcome measures to evaluate response to therapy. Assessment typically includes observation and analysis of stance and gait during walking, trotting, and selected functional activities such as stair climbing. The evaluation also includes a general physical examination, a detailed orthopedic examination, and a brief neurological examination to rule out concurrent spinal pain or ataxia. The orthopedic examination includes evaluation of joint motion and stability, measurement of range of motion using goniometry, limb girth measurements, and assessment of functional mobility and strength. Baseline assessment should include detailed documentation of both objective and subjective measures so that response to therapy and disease progression can be monitored over time. Comprehensive rehabilitation assessments are described in greater detail in other resources (41–44). Key parameters that influence the development of an OA management plan are discussed below.
Joint range of motion (ROM)
OA can result in loss of joint motion; however, not all joints affected by OA demonstrate loss of motion and the degree of restriction varies widely among dogs (9). Range of motion (ROM) is often measured at baseline and during follow-up examinations, particularly when abnormal joint motion is observed or suspected. Adequate joint motion is necessary for dogs to stand and move without restriction. Reduced ROM can negatively affect mobility (for example, limiting the ability to climb stairs or to transition from sitting to standing), may exacerbate chronic pain, and could lead to compensatory changes in other joints, the spine, and associated musculature. Increasing joint motion is therefore an important therapeutic goal when a joint lacks the mobility required for normal daily activities.
Range of motion is typically measured using goniometry, in which a goniometer is aligned with anatomical landmarks proximal and distal to the joint while the limb is passively moved through flexion and extension to quantify the joint angle in degrees (45). The severity of motion restriction helps guide therapeutic interventions such as targeted exercises, manual stretching, and joint mobilization techniques (46). Goniometric measurements provide objective data that can be used to monitor response to therapy or detect deterioration associated with disease progression (47). Traditional goniometers are inexpensive, easy to use, and have been shown to provide greater accuracy than smartphone or digital measurement tools (48). Anatomic landmarks and normal ranges of joint motion have been described (43, 44, 47, 48). Individual dogs also differ in their standing joint angles; some exhibit more upright posture, while others maintain a more flexed or crouched stance (49).
Muscle mass assessment
Reduced weight bearing associated with pain, OA, and compensatory gait patterns commonly leads to muscle atrophy. Muscle girth should therefore be measured at baseline and monitored at regular intervals during treatment. Several techniques can be used to assess muscle mass, including limb girth measurements, ultrasound, CT, MRI, and dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) (50–52). Limb girth measurement is the most practical method in clinical settings because it is simple and inexpensive. However, measurements are influenced by the technique used and must be performed consistently to allow meaningful comparison over time (13, 50, 51, 53).
Functional mobility and strength assessment
In human physical therapy, functional mobility tests, strength assessments, and task-specific challenges are routinely used to establish treatment goals, design therapy programs, and provide measurable outcomes (54–59). Similar functional assessment tools have been explored for use in dogs, although their validation remains limited (43). Proposed tests for evaluating mobility in dogs include the Timed Up and Go, Cavaletti rails, Figure of 8s, and Down to Stand (43). The Timed Up and Go (TUG) test has recently been validated for use in dogs and provides a practical and objective measure of functional mobility by recording the time required for a dog to rise from a stationary position and walk a short distance (60, 61). These tests may provide useful information about functional performance and may help monitor changes in mobility over time.
Activity monitoring and wearable sensors
Activity monitoring has been used to assess mobility and activity patterns in dogs. In general, larger and older dogs tend to be less active than younger and smaller dogs (62). An increase in activity of approximately 20% was reported following administration of pain medication in dogs with OA in one study (63), whereas no change in activity was detected after weight loss in another study (64). Early activity monitoring systems were considered somewhat subjective due to limited accuracy (65) and uncertainty regarding the relationship between activity levels and clinical measures of mobility or pain (66). However, advances in sensor technology and data analysis have improved the performance of wearable activity monitors (67, 68). As a result, their use as objective outcome measures in clinical trials of OA treatments in dogs has increased (69, 70).
Management options
Therapeutic exercise is considered the cornerstone of physical rehabilitation in dogs with OA because it directly addresses strength, mobility, and functional capacity. Exercise programs typically include both static and dynamic activities. Static exercises emphasize postural control and foundational stability, which are important for all patients regardless of their clinical patient profile, severity of OA, activity level or performance demands. One structured example is the Fit to Work program, developed by the Penn Vet Working Dog Center at the University of Pennsylvania (39). The program incorporates a fitness assessment, structured exercises, and progressive exercise advancement tailored to individual dogs.
Walking is the most common form of exercise in dogs and has been evaluated in several studies. Longer daily exercise duration (> 60 min/day) has been associated with a decrease in the severity of lameness in dogs with hip dysplasia compared with limited daily exercise (< 20 min/day) (9). Incline and decline walking have also been evaluated for their effects on joint motion and can be incorporated into targeted exercise programs (58, 59). Other dynamic exercises that can be used to selectively influence joint range of motion include Cavaletti poles and stair exercises (58, 59, 71–75). These exercises can be selected, modified, and progressed based on the desired joint effects (e.g., improving hip extension or elbow flexion) as well as the specific muscle groups being targeted. For each exercise, baseline frequency, intensity, and duration should be selected based on the dog's current abilities and owner factors. These parameters are modified over time, based on response to therapy and on the ability of the owner to sustain the exercise program.
Hydrotherapy involves the therapeutic use of water and commonly includes underwater treadmill exercise and swimming (76). Joint motion effects differ substantially between underwater treadmill therapy and swimming, which can influence the selection of therapy when specific range-of-motion or loading effects are desired. Underwater treadmill therapy allows controlled weight-bearing exercise, whereas swimming typically produces greater joint flexion with minimal limb loading. Muscle activation during underwater treadmill exercise also varies with water depth due to the interaction between limb motion and the physical properties of water. Adjusting water level can therefore influence joint loading, range of motion, and muscle recruitment during therapy (77, 78).
Manual therapy includes massage, stretching, joint mobilization, myofascial release, and traction. These techniques can assist with both assessment and treatment of musculoskeletal pain. Palpation of affected tissues provides valuable information about the source and severity of pain associated with joint motion or tissue compression. Passive range of motion (PROM) exercises provide non-painful sensory stimulation, may reduce swelling, and gently stretch periarticular tissues. PROM has been reported to relieve pain in some patients (79). Many owners can be trained to perform PROM exercises at home. Massage may also be beneficial to dogs with OA by providing non-noxious sensory stimulation, improving venous and lymphatic drainage, and potentially promoting endorphin and serotonin release. In humans with knee OA, manual therapy combined with exercise has been shown to provide greater benefit than electrophysical modalities combined with exercise (80). Although massage has demonstrated benefits in humans with OA (81), controlled studies evaluating manual therapy for chronic pain management in dogs remain limited (82–85).
Photobiomodulation therapy (PBMT), also known as low-level laser therapy or cold laser therapy, uses light at specific wavelengths to influence cellular activity. PBMT may affect pain perception by altering peripheral and central neurochemistry, afferent nerve conduction, and endorphin release, thereby increasing pain thresholds. PBMT also produces several physiologic effects, including increased myofibroblast activity, enhanced collagen and cartilage synthesis, increased tenocyte and myocyte activity, and increased ATP production through altered mitochondrial oxygen utilization. Additional effects include improved blood flow through angiogenesis and vasodilation, as well as stimulation of axonal sprouting in the peripheral and central nervous systems (86). Clinical trials evaluating PBMT in dogs have produced mixed results, possibly due to small sample sizes and variability in treatment protocols (87, 88). Optimal dosing parameters for PBMT in dogs remain unknown.
Pulsed electromagnetic field therapy (PEMF) modulates the calcium-calmodulin nitric oxide cascade and downregulates IL-1β, thereby reducing inflammation (89). In humans, PEMF has demonstrated small to moderate benefits in the treatment of knee OA (90–92). In dogs, randomized controlled studies have shown reductions in postoperative pain and OA-associated pain, as well as improved neurologic recovery after thoracolumbar intervertebral disc extrusion (93, 94). PEMF devices used in veterinary medicine commonly deliver therapy through loops or treatment mats.
Extracorporeal shockwave therapy uses high-energy acoustic waves that release mechanical energy when they encounter changes in tissue density. Shockwave therapy stimulates the production of cytokines and growth factors, endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) and bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) expression. In veterinary medicine, ESWT has most commonly been investigated for treatment of tendon and ligament injuries and for stimulation of bone healing rather than specifically for OA management (95, 96). However, studies in humans suggest that ESWT may be beneficial for OA treatment (97–99).
Thermal therapy—Cold therapy decreases inflammation, histamine release, and edema. It may also decrease pain by reducing muscle spasm, lowering prostaglandin concentration, and slowing nerve conduction. Heat therapy increases blood flow, promotes muscle relaxation, and improves tissue extensibility (100–106).
Acupuncture modulates the activity within the peripheral, central, and autonomic nervous systems. Acupuncture alters the pain pathway through the release of neurochemicals, including enkephalins, endorphins, dynorphins, serotonin, norepinephrine, glutamate, neurokinin, and cannabinoids (107, 108). More recently, research focused on acupuncture as a neuromodulatory intervention, capable of influencing pain-related neuroplasticity (hyperalgesia/allodynia) and reducing neuroinflammation in the spinal cord (109, 110). Randomized controlled trials investigating the benefits of OA management using acupuncture show mixed results (111–113), but the body of evidence supporting the use of acupuncture in OA management is increasing as more trials are performed.
Environmental modifications represent an ergonomic strategy for dogs that have difficulties performing routine activities. Modifications may include improving floor traction, installing ramps, adjusting bedding, and modifying the height and location of food and water bowls. Additional supportive measures include foot care (such as nail trimming, hair trimming, and traction aids) and mobility assistance devices including harnesses and ambulation carts.
Applying rehabilitation strategies based on OA risk
Physical rehabilitation planning integrates findings from the patient assessment with owner goals, expectations, and practical considerations (41, 74). Individualized exercise plans and activity modification form the foundation of rehabilitation programs for dogs with OA (41). Additional therapies, including manual therapy, electrophysical modalities, and environmental modifications, may be incorporated depending on the patient's needs and the available evidence supporting their use. Because the strength of evidence varies across rehabilitation interventions, preference should be given to strategies supported by robust scientific data.
Healthy adult dog/low OA risk
A rehabilitation evaluation may be beneficial even for dogs presenting without owner concerns, as underlying problems may otherwise remain undetected. Potential findings include mild conformational abnormalities, myofascial trigger points, muscle tension, reduced flexibility, or muscle imbalance (114). When risk factors for OA are minimal, rehabilitation planning primarily focuses on maintaining fitness, lean body mass, and musculoskeletal strength. Exercise programs typically emphasize general physical conditioning and are tailored to the dog's routine activities, sport participation, or working role.
Healthy adult dog/high OA risk
Dogs at increased risk of OA benefit from periodic reassessment to detect early changes in gait, posture, mobility, or pain responses to palpation. In addition to maintaining general fitness, exercise programs may target strengthening of joints that are predisposed to OA. For example, dogs with hip laxity that are at high risk of developing hip OA may benefit from exercises designed to strengthen the gluteal and thigh musculature with the aim to improve joint stability.
Adult dog with clinical OA
In dogs with established OA, rehabilitation planning is guided by the clinical assessment. Affected dogs commonly exhibit altered posture or gait, pain on palpation, reduced joint motion due to capsular thickening, muscle atrophy, and compromised mobility. Initial rehabilitation goals focus on minimizing pain during activity and restoring functional mobility through targeted exercises (41). Selection of therapeutic interventions is based on the rehabilitation assessment, owner expectations, and available evidence supporting treatment efficacy. Environmental modifications may also be implemented when mobility limitations interfere with daily activities.
Physical wellness: key points
Physical wellness is a central component of OA management in dogs. Maintaining fitness and mobility begins with a baseline evaluation followed by exercise programs tailored to the individual patient and owner. Regular daily activity is one of the most effective strategies for preserving musculoskeletal health. Careful control of exercise intensity and duration helps reduce the likelihood of symptom flares.
Nutritional supplementation for adult dogs
Diet and nutritional supplements (nutraceuticals) recommended for adult dogs with OA aim to reduce inflammation, improve function, and potentially slow disease progression (2). Nutritional supplementation generally has an excellent safety profile. As in growing dogs with OA, nutritional supplements are commonly incorporated into the overall health management of adult dogs with OA (2).
Healthy adult dog/low OA risk
Adult dogs at low risk of developing OA should maintain an optimal body condition. In these dogs, nutritional supplementation is most often considered in the context of training or engaging in strenuous sporting or working activities. In these situations, supplements may be used to support musculoskeletal health, enhance performance capacity, or potentially protect joints from activity-related stress.
Healthy adult dog/high OA risk
Healthy adult dogs with musculoskeletal conformational abnormalities, dogs that engage in high-intensity work or sport, and dogs from breeds predisposed to early-onset OA are considered at higher risk for developing OA, particularly since some strenuous activities increase the risk of injury. Maintaining optimal body weight is particularly important in these patients. The supplements recommended for adult dogs with OA are generally similar to those recommended for growing dogs with OA and include omega-3 fatty acids, undenatured type II collagen, glucosamine and chondroitin (2). Most of the available scientific evidence supporting nutritional supplementation has been generated in studies involving adult dogs (3).
Adult dog with clinical OA
Nutritional supplementation for adult dogs with clinical OA typically includes the same supplements recommended for high-risk dogs including omega-3 fatty acids, undenatured type II collagen, glucosamine and chondroitin (2). Comorbidities such as obesity and chronic renal disease are relatively common in adult dogs with OA. The presence of renal or gastrointestinal comorbidities may increase the risk of adverse events associated with pharmacologic pain management, which may increase the appeal of nutritional supplementation as an adjunct or alternative to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). Nutritional supplementation has been associated with increased weight bearing in affected limbs and a reduced perceived need for pain medications such as NSAIDs in some studies (3, 115).
Omega-3 fatty acids
Omega-3 fatty acids are a key nutritional supplement used to reduce joint inflammation. Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) promotes the production of eicosanoids that are less pro-inflammatory than the byproducts of arachidonic acid catabolism (2). Supplements derived from marine sources of omega-3 fatty acids are generally more effective than short-chain plant sources such as flax seed oil (116). In one study, a diet containing 3.5% omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil decreased pain and lameness, improved weight bearing, and reduced the need for NSAIDs in dogs with OA (117). Achieving similar omega-3 concentrations through supplementation alone would require approximately 480 mg/kg of fish oil (50 to 100 mg/kg EPA), which may be costly and impractical in some cases. Green-lipped mussel extracts provide an alternate source of omega-3 fatty acids and also contain glycosaminoglycans and chondroitin sulfate. These extracts are lower in calories because the active compounds are more concentrated (118). Supplementation with green-lipped mussel extracts has been shown to benefit dogs with OA (119) and may enhance the effectiveness of NSAIDs (118).
Undenatured collagen type II (UC-II®)
Supplementation with undenatured type II collagen is based on the principle that sustained oral administration increases the immune tolerance to collagen byproducts present in joints with OA (3). UC-II, a patented form of undenatured type II collagen derived from chicken sternum, has demonstrated safety and efficacy in several clinical studies in dogs (3). In a prospective controlled clinical trial, undenatured type II collagen supplementation decreased inflammation, cartilage catabolism, and soreness following strenuous activity in healthy field-trial dogs (120, 121). In dogs with OA, undenatured type II collagen supplementation has been associated with objective improvements in limb use measured using force-plate gait analysis in multiple studies (122–125). In one clinical trial comparing undenatured type II collagen supplementation with NSAIDs in dogs with OA, both treatments produced similar benefits (115, 126).
Glucosamine/chondroitin supplements
Glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate (GCS) supplements are among the most used joint supplements in dogs. While the anti-inflammatory activity has been demonstrated (127), clinical efficacy of GCS supplements in dogs with OA has been inconsistent: some clinical trials report improvement (128), whereas others do not demonstrate significant benefits (129, 130). These mixed findings have led some authors to conclude that glucosamine and chondroitin provide limited therapeutic benefit (3).
Eggshell membrane supplementation
Eggshell membrane (ESM) extracts are used as nutritional supplements and contain collagen, glucosamine, glycosaminoglycans, elastin, hyaluronic acid, and various amino acids and proteins. Many formulations combine ESM with additional compounds such as astaxanthin, krill oil, and hyaluronic acid. In vitro studies suggest that ESM may modulate the inflammatory pathways and potentially reduce cartilage degradation. The scientific evidence supporting eggshell membrane use in OA management is limited overall. Two pilot studies in Labrador retrievers demonstrated decreased concentrations of the inflammatory biomarker interleukin-6 (IL-6) following ESM supplementation; however, LOAD scores did not improve (131, 132). In a 90-day controlled clinical trial, ESM supplementation resulted in improved CBPI and LOAD scores (133).
Supplementation to manage the potential loss of muscle mass
Sarcopenia refers to the gradual loss of muscle mass, quality, and strength that occurs with aging. Muscle loss associated with cachexia or sarcopenia involves increased myocyte apoptosis and reduced regenerative capacity (134). In humans, sarcopenia is associated with frailty, increased risk of physical disability, reduced quality of life, and mortality (135). Pro-inflammatory cytokines including IL-6, IL-1β, transforming growth factor-β (TGF-β), and tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) contribute to muscle fiber breakdown (136). Information regarding sarcopenia in dogs with chronic OA is limited. In one study of Labrador retrievers 8 years old and older, sarcopenia in the absence of an increase in inflammatory mediators was a predictor of early mortality (137). Clinically, OA-associated limb disuse is widely believed to contribute to muscle atrophy in dogs. Because preservation of muscle mass is closely associated with maintenance of physical function in humans (135), strategies that support muscle mass may also benefit dogs with OA.
Fortetropin® is a nonthermal-pasteurized, freeze-dried, fertilized egg yolk product used to support muscle mass in dogs. Myostatin, a myokine belonging to the TGF-β family, regulates muscle growth through effects on activin receptors (ACVR2A/B) (135). Fortetropin is believed to promote muscle growth by reducing circulating myostatin concentrations. Several studies in dogs demonstrate an inverse relationship between myostatin expression and muscle mass (138). In one trial involving dogs with OA, improvement in LOAD scores was observed between 6 and 12 weeks of supplementation, although differences from placebo were not statistically significant (137). In another study evaluating muscle atrophy following stifle surgery, dogs receiving Fortetropin experienced less postoperative muscle loss than the controls (139).
Ursolyx™ contains ursolic acid which is a plant-derived pentacyclic triterpene compound with anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, anti-carcinogenic, anti-obesity, and thermogenic properties (136). Mechanistically, ursolic acid influences gene expression in skeletal muscle cells, supporting cellular pathways involved in maintaining muscle structure and function (140). In dogs, dietary supplementation with ursolic acid has been associated with increased skeletal muscle mass, muscle quality, strength, and endurance (140). In one study on age-related muscle atrophy, ursolic acid supplementation suppressed more than 50 molecular markers associated with muscle loss while activating markers associated with muscle health and exercise capacity (140).
Cannabis supplementation
The main phytocannabinoids used as supplements are cannabidiol (CBD) and Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol (Δ9-THC). Based on the presence of a range of receptors involved in inflammation and analgesia in the pain pathway that CBD interacts with, CBD likely plays a role in analgesia. In one study, a CBD product was used safely to manage clinical signs of OA in 22 dogs (141). Because cannabis-derived compounds are regulated as drugs rather than nutritional supplements in many jurisdictions, local regulatory requirements should be reviewed before recommending, prescribing, or dispensing cannabis nutraceutical supplements.
While several clinical studies using phytocannabinoids have been published (141–145), no study used pharmaceutical-grade CBD. Therefore, little is known about the clinical safety and efficacy of pharmaceutical-grade CBD in dogs. The use of CBD-rich hemp nutraceuticals appears promising in dogs. CBD-rich hemp has been used in combination with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), prednisone, amitriptyline, and gabapentin, without any serious adverse events in short-term studies. This suggests that pharmaceutical-grade CBD could be beneficial to multimodal pain management. CBD-rich hemp has also been used as a single agent (141, 142) and appears to be effective for the management of OA pain in dogs. Differences in dosing among studies may have resulted from differences among products used. In the absence of FDA regulation, the efficacy and safety of CBD-rich hemp cannot be confirmed. Clinicians can select CBD supplements with positive clinical trial evidence in dogs.
Nutritional supplements: key points
Most nutritional supplements have a favorable safety profile. They appear most effective at reducing inflammatory pain associated with chronic OA. Some supplements may provide additional benefits not addressed by other therapies, such as improving the tolerance to collagen degradation byproducts (undenatured type II collagen) or supporting preservation of muscle mass (fortetropin, ursolic acid). Overall, information about the size of the effects of nutraceuticals used in chronic OA in dogs is lacking. When managing OA in humans, glucosamine-chondroitin and undenatured type II collagen have mild-to-moderate effects to relieve signs of OA and some herbal formulations have large and clinically significant effects (146).
Pharmaceutical management of OA in adult dogs
Medications are the most widely used strategy to alleviate the pain signs of OA in dogs, likely because of their predictable efficacy, convenience of administration, generally acceptable safety profiles, and relatively low cost. The drugs used to manage OA in dogs belong to several pharmacologic classes. The pharmacologic treatment options for adult dogs with OA are shown in Table 1. Most pharmacologic agents act by reducing inflammation or modulating pain-related neurotransmission, although some agents target joint structure or cartilage metabolism, such as polysulfated glycosaminoglycans. The strength of scientific evidence supporting the efficacy of these drugs varies widely. NSAIDs have robust evidence supporting their ability to relieve pain and improve function, whereas other drug classes have limited or inconsistent evidence. Safety profiles also vary. Although adverse drug events are uncommon overall, they can range from mild and transient effects (e.g., a single episode of vomiting) to severe complications, including life-threatening illness or death (147).
Table 1. Treatment options, including pharmacologic options, for adult dogs with OA.
| OA stage | Drugs | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Healthy adult dog/low OA risk | None needed | ± Weight and nutritional optimization |
| Healthy adult dog/high OA risk | Likely none needed | Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation |
| Adult dog with clinical OA | Mild pain | NSAIDs Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation |
| Moderate pain | NSAIDs or antiNGF mAbs, if tolerated ± Gabapentinoid or/and NMDA receptor antagonist Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation ± Environmental modifications ± Intraarticular therapy | |
| Severe pain | NSAIDs and/or antiNGF mAbs, if tolerated in the long term Gabapentinoid or/and NMDA receptor antagonist Weight and nutritional optimization/supplementation Environmental modifications ± Intraarticular therapy |
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
NSAIDs are potent analgesics that primarily reduce pain by inhibiting prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) production. Several NSAIDs are FDA-approved for both acute and chronic pain management in dogs. Because of their predictable efficacy in most dogs with OA, NSAIDs are widely considered the cornerstone of pharmacologic management of OA (3, 148, 149). Detailed reviews of NSAID use in dogs are available elsewhere (150). Both veterinarians and owners observe improvement in most dogs receiving NSAIDs. In one study of 1,000 dogs treated with an NSAID for 40 days, two-thirds of dogs improved within 14 days and three-quarters improved by 40 days (151). Most NSAIDs inhibit cyclooxygenase (COX)-1 and COX-2 enzymes. Grapiprant differs mechanistically from traditional NSAIDs by selectively inhibiting the EP4 receptor of prostaglandin E2. This targeted mechanism may reduce the risk of adverse events commonly associated with COX inhibition, such as vomiting, gastrointestinal ulceration, and acute kidney injury (152–155). Grapiprant is effective when treating dogs with OA (153, 156). In one clinical study, grapiprant was more effective than meloxicam to manage postoperative joint pain (157).
Anti-nerve growth factor monoclonal antibodies (antiNGF mAbs)
Anti-nerve growth factor monoclonal antibodies (anti-NGF mAbs) are analgesic drugs that inhibit nerve growth factor (NGF) signaling. Bedinvetmab is an anti-NGF mAb that is FDA-approved for the control of OA pain in dogs, and is administered as a once-monthly subcutaneous injection. The clinical effects of anti-NGF mAbs have been described in several studies (4, 158, 159). Their analgesic efficacy in dogs with OA appears comparable with that of NSAIDs (160). The safety profile of anti-NGF mAbs differs from that of NSAIDs. Adverse events appear uncommon overall (160), but reports describe exacerbation of neurologic disease and the progression of joint degeneration in some cases (161–163). Several potentially different patterns of joint degeneration have been described, including rapid progression of joint degeneration, atypical periarticular bone remodeling, and extensive heterotopic periarticular mineralization, a process also named insidious anti-nerve growth factor-induced periarticular mineralization (163–165).
Polysulfated glycosaminoglycans
Polysulfated glycosaminoglycans (PSGAGs) are disease-modifying agents that may influence cartilage metabolism and inflammation. A single PSGAG (Adequan) is approved by the FDA for the treatment of OA in dogs, and is administered as a series of 8 intramuscular injections given twice weekly. The beneficial effects of PSGAGs may be partly mediated by reductions in inflammatory mediators within the joint. In a pivotal study, growing dogs with hip dysplasia that received PSGAG between 2 and 10 months of age developed less cartilage damage and less joint laxity compared with untreated control dogs (166). Compounds related to PSGAG, such as pentosan polysulphate, have been used outside the United States for OA management. Beyond NSAIDs, anti-NGF mAbs, and PSGAG, the evidence supporting other pharmacologic classes used to manage OA pain in dogs is substantially more limited (4).
Gabapentin and pregabalin
Gabapentinoids bind to the α2 δ-1 subunit of presynaptic voltage-gated calcium channels, reducing the release of excitatory neurotransmitters. These drugs are primarily intended to alleviate neuropathic pain. Gabapentin and pregabalin typically require administration two or three times daily to maintain therapeutic effects. Adverse effects may include transient sedation and ataxia. Commonly suggested doses are 10 to 20 mg/kg every 8 h for gabapentin (167) and 4 mg/kg every 12 h for pregabalin (168, 169). Optimal dosing in dogs remains uncertain, which may lead to underdosing in clinical practice. Gabapentin is frequently used as part of multimodal pain management strategies in dogs with chronic pain; however, evidence supporting its efficacy for OA-related pain is limited (128).
Amantadine and ketamine
Amantadine and ketamine are N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonists that act within the central nervous system. By inhibiting NMDA receptor activity in the spinal cord, NMDA receptor antagonism may help prevent or reverse central sensitization (“pain wind-up”) although they may not provide direct analgesic effects. In one clinical trial, amantadine administered once daily in combination with an NSAID increased activity levels in dogs with OA (170). Twice-daily dosing may provide greater benefit than once-daily administration (4, 167). Ketamine is sometimes used anecdotally to manage chronic pain when administered intermittently subcutaneously, at 0.5 mg/kg, or intravenously as a continuous rate infusion, typically at approximately 10 μg/kg/min for 4 h or longer.
Opioids
Opioids are not commonly used for long-term management of chronic OA pain in dogs and are generally less effective for control of chronic pain than other analgesic classes. However, they may be useful for managing severe or breakthrough pain. Opioids are tightly regulated and commonly produce adverse effects, including sedation, nausea, and constipation. Increasing dietary fiber may help mitigate constipation in dogs receiving opioids chronically. The efficacy of orally administered opioids in dogs appears limited, possibly because of relatively poor oral bioavailability (167).
Tramadol
Tramadol is an opioid-like analgesic with additional serotonergic and noradrenergic activity. In dogs, its analgesic effects are believed to result primarily from norepinephrine reuptake inhibition rather than classic opioid receptor activation. Dogs lack sufficient metabolic conversion of tramadol to its opioid-active metabolite (O-desmethyltramadol, M1), thus tramadol produces negligible μ-opioid receptor–mediated analgesic effects (171). When used alone, tramadol does not appear to provide meaningful relief of OA pain in dogs (117). However, some studies suggest that tramadol may provide additional benefit when combined with NSAIDs (172).
Antidepressants
Tricyclic antidepressants such as amitriptyline have been considered for the management of chronic pain (169). Serotonin-norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs), including duloxetine, venlafaxine, desvenlafaxine, and milnacipran, are used to treat chronic pain in humans. However, information regarding their efficacy or safety in dogs with OA is currently lacking.
Lidocaine
Lidocaine is occasionally administered as a continuous rate infusion in dogs with severe pain. In human medicine, perioperative lidocaine infusions reduce the risk of chronic pain development (173) and decrease opioid requirements (174).
Glucocorticoids (corticosteroids)
Glucocorticoids are potent anti-inflammatory drugs but are associated with significant systemic adverse effects, particularly with long-term administration (150). Consequently, the use of systemic glucocorticoids for chronic OA management in dogs has become uncommon.
Intra-articular injections
Unlike humans and horses (175, 176), the use of intra-articular (IA) injections to manage OA in dogs is relatively uncommon (177). IA injections include corticosteroids, hyaluronic acid, platelet rich plasma, autologous stem cells, bone marrow aspirate concentrate, stromal vascular fraction, polyacrylamide hydrogels (PAAG), and radioactive tin (tin-117m radiosynoviorthesis). IA injections in dogs are most often given under sedation. They require hair clipping and sterile preparation of the injection site. IA injections appear safe overall. Complications include a temporary increase in pain and lameness and septic arthritis. In one report evaluating the response to the IA injection of various products, one dog in five (18.4%) showed signs of pain after IA, with a median pain duration of 2 days (178). In that report, pain was mostly associated with the injection of stem cells.
Corticosteroids
Corticosteroids have a powerful anti-inflammatory action (150). Methylprednisolone acetate (up to 20 mg per joint) and triamcinolone acetonide (1 to 3 mg per joint) are used most often in dogs. Typical pain relief is visible after 12 to 24 h and can last up to 6 months (179). Side effects such as polyuria, polydipsia, or polyphagia are uncommon. However, corticosteroids appear to negatively impact cartilage and synovium, even after a single exposure (180). These adverse effects may not be present after triamcinolone exposure (181).
Hyaluronic acid (HA)
HA (sodium hyaluronate, hyaluronan) is a ubiquitous sugar glycosaminoglycan molecule present in all living organisms. HA binds to CD44 receptors on chondrocytes, inducing cellular proliferation and extracellular matrix production, stimulating synoviocytes to synthesize hyaluronan, an endogenous glycosaminoglycan, inhibiting inflammatory mediators, and exerting an anti-apoptotic effect on chondrocytes (182). Intra-articular HA aims to restore the physical properties of joint fluid to aid in joint lubrication, to decrease inflammation and degradation, and to help in cartilage repair (183). Several HA formulations are available for intra-articular injection. The use of high-molecular-weight HA is recommended because it more closely mimics naturally occurring HA. In a trial comparing high-molecular-weight HA to stem cell therapy, HA appeared more effective than stem cell therapy (184). However, the clinical benefits of IA HA appear modest overall, and IA HA is most often used in combination with other products.
Hydrogels
Several hydrogels are used clinically to manage OA in dogs. Collagen elastin hydrogel microparticles (CEHM) are manufactured from a purified self-assembling composition of collagen, elastin, and heparin. The peer-reviewed information documenting the efficacy of CEHM is limited. In one trial, the clinical response to CEHM and triamcinolone in dogs with OA did not differ from the response to triamcinolone alone (185). Polyacrylamide hydrogels provide viscosupplementation and act as a joint lubricant. Polyacrylamide hydrogels are available with several concentrations: the 2.5% polyacrylamide appears to be incorporated into synovium and 4% binds to cartilage (186, 187). The 2.5% polyacrylamide concentration appears safe and effective in human and equine OA patients (188, 189). In a dog owner survey (100 dogs, 150 injected joints), 10% of owners reported mild and self-limiting adverse events and 82% of owners considered their dog improved (190).
Regenerative medicine
Regenerative products (orthobiologics) include blood-derived and fat-derived products. Blood-derived products include platelet-rich plasma (PRP), autologous conditioned serum (ACS) or plasma (ACP), bone marrow aspirate, and bone marrow aspirate concentrate (BMAC). Fat-derived products include stromal vascular fraction (SVF) obtained from adipose tissue, either used directly or after culture and expansion. In the United States, the FDA classified orthobiologics as drugs (191). The most common orthobiologics used in dogs are autologous (patient-derived). PRP used alone or in combination with HA appears to be the most widely used orthobiologic product (192). Adipose or bone marrow stem cells have been used in dogs with OA and appear beneficial overall (193). Allogenic orthobiologic treatments are emerging, but evidence of their efficacy is currently lacking (194).
Radionuclide tin-117m
Radioactive tin-117m is approved by the FDA for management of synovitis in the dog elbow. The tin radionuclide emits low-energy electrons that promote necrosis of inflamed synovial cells. The clinical safety and the efficacy of radioactive tin-117m have been evaluated in small case series (195–197), and the treatment appears safe overall (198).
Potential cytotoxicity (i.e., chondrotoxicity) should be considered for all compounds injected into joints. Several local anesthetics (lidocaine, bupivacaine, ropivacaine) and corticosteroids (triamcinolone) are chondrotoxic (199). Chondrotoxicity appears to be mitigated when compounds are injected in combination with hyaluronic acid. Information about the chondrotoxicity of PRP is lacking (199). In one survey of 174 practitioners, 94% of respondents used IA therapy (200). The elbow was the most common joint injected. Platelet rich plasma and viscosupplements were the most commonly injected products.
Pharmaceutical management: key points
NSAIDs remain the cornerstone of pharmacologic management for OA in dogs. Several adjunctive medications may provide additional benefit and generally have acceptable safety profiles, although their efficacy is less consistent than that of NSAIDs. A growing number of injectable therapies are available and may provide short-term clinical improvement, but evidence regarding their long-term effectiveness remains limited.
Surgical interventions for management of OA in the adult dog
Surgery may be performed in joints affected by OA either with a therapeutic intent or as a salvage procedure. Therapeutic surgery aims to address the underlying cause of joint disease and may include removal of intra-articular osteochondral fragments, improvement of joint congruity or stability, or replacement of damaged cartilage with grafted cartilage. Salvage procedures include excision, replacement, or fusion of the affected joint.
Hip joint
Hip dysplasia is the most common cause of OA in the hip joint (201) and is likely the most common orthopedic disorder in dogs. Other conditions that may lead to hip OA include Legg-Calvé-Perthes disease and fractures involving the femoral head growth plate (202). In dogs with hip dysplasia, OA typically progresses gradually over the course of a lifetime (8, 203), and excess body weight accelerates disease progression (203). Surgical procedures aimed at improving hip stability include juvenile pubic symphysiodesis, typically performed at approximately 16 weeks of age, and double pelvic osteotomy, generally performed around 6 months of age. Salvage procedures for advanced disease include femoral head and neck excision and total hip replacement (204). Evidence supporting the long-term efficacy of early therapeutic procedures for preventing OA progression is limited. In contrast, total hip replacement is associated with favorable long-term outcomes, but the surgery is complex and costly.
Stifle joint
In the stifle joint, cranial cruciate ligament degeneration or rupture (CCLR) and patellar luxation are the most common causes of OA (11). Because owner satisfaction tends to be higher after surgical treatment compared with conservative management (205), CCLR is often treated surgically. Common surgical procedures include tibial osteotomy techniques and extracapsular stabilization using prosthetic material. Overall, outcomes following osteotomy procedures appear slightly superior to those achieved with extracapsular stabilization (206). Surgical correction is also frequently performed for patellar luxation (207). The goals of surgery are to restore proper patellar tracking within the trochlear groove and to realign the extensor mechanism of the stifle (i.e., the quadriceps muscle, patella, and patellar ligament). Surgical techniques are selected based on the severity of malalignment and may include trochlear deepening procedures, tibial tuberosity transposition, and soft tissue imbrication (207). Surgical treatment generally has a high success rate. However, because long-term studies evaluating OA progression after surgical correction are limited, it remains unclear whether OA progression continues following stabilization of the patella.
Tarsal joint
OA of the tarsus is uncommon relative to the hip and elbow. It most often develops secondary to osteochondritis dissecans of the talus, intra-articular fractures, or from a traumatic luxation. Severe tarsal OA is typically managed with arthrodesis. Total ankle replacement and fitted exoprostheses are rarely used in dogs (208).
Shoulder joint
OA of the shoulder is relatively common (209), although its underlying cause is often unclear. Osteochondritis dissecans of the humeral head is responsible for OA in a subset of dogs (202). Shoulder injuries are also reported to be the most common musculoskeletal injury in dogs participating in agility (210). These injuries may result in joint instability or, in severe cases, luxation. Surgical stabilization may be performed in dogs with significant shoulder instability (211). In cases of severe or chronic instability, shoulder arthrodesis may be considered as a salvage procedure.
Elbow joint
OA of the elbow joint is common and most frequently develops secondary to elbow dysplasia (202), which typically affects the medial compartment of the joint (19). Surgical procedures intended to address elbow dysplasia include the arthroscopic or open removal of osteochondral fragments, joint resurfacing procedures, and osteotomies of the ulna or humerus. However, the scientific evidence supporting the efficacy of these procedures is limited (212). Total elbow replacement is rarely performed in dogs (213).
Carpal joint
OA of the carpus is uncommon. It may develop following hyperextension injuries, intra-articular fractures, or immune-mediated disease. Severe instability and advanced carpal OA are most-commonly treated with carpal arthrodesis.
Surgical management of OA: key points
OA most commonly affects the hip and elbow joints in dogs, largely due to the high prevalence of hip and elbow dysplasia. During the early stages of disease, a variety of surgical procedures may be performed to address the underlying cause or potentially slow OA progression, although evidence supporting the long-term efficacy of these interventions is limited.
Integrating all approaches to manage OA in adult dogs
Epidemiological surveys suggest that approximately one in four adult dogs is affected by OA. Clinical signs vary widely, ranging from no detectable abnormalities to severe disability. However, many affected dogs experience persistent joint inflammation and pain. Effective management therefore aims to minimize the current impact of OA, slow disease progression, and optimize the dog's overall lifestyle. The physiologic impact of OA is primarily joint inflammation, which can be managed with medications, appropriate nutrition, and nutritional supplementation. The physical consequences of OA include pain and a potential loss of strength and fitness. These are addressed through pain management, physical activity, therapeutic exercise, and weight optimization. The functional impact of OA often manifests as reduced propulsion, decreased mobility, and diminished endurance, which may be improved through lifestyle modifications and ergonomic support.
Treatment plans should be individualized and influenced by the severity and chronicity of OA as well as by patient and owner factors (74). Although a wide range of therapeutic options is available, for many owners it is not feasible to implement all possible interventions. This underscores the importance of the veterinarian's role in counseling the owner when considering treatment options for particular patients and situations. It is important take owner goals and priorities into consideration, and streamline therapy whenever possible. Minimizing burden of treatment in terms of cost, time, effort, and risk may be beneficial in encouraging owners to pursue OA treatment fort their dog.
In most cases, OA is initially managed conservatively without surgery. The core components of conservative management include optimized nutrition and nutritional supplementation, analgesic medications, appropriate physical activity, and lifestyle modifications. These approaches can provide meaningful short-term relief and may also contribute to long-term joint health. Pharmacologic therapy is typically initiated with oral medications, most commonly NSAIDs, if they are well tolerated. The use of NSAIDs alone appears sufficient to improve joint pain and function in more than half of dogs with OA (151). When response to NSAIDs is incomplete, alternative therapeutics like anti-NGF mAbs and/or adjunctive oral medications are often considered, followed by intra-articular medications. Additional management strategies may also be considered when dogs cannot be adequately managed with weight optimization, nutritional supplementation, lifestyle modification, and pharmacologic therapy alone. These adjunctive options include electrophysical modalities, manual therapy, therapeutic exercise programs, and ergonomic support.
Among the available interventions, maintaining optimal body condition has the strongest evidence for long-term protection against OA progression (5, 6). Evidence also supports the benefits of regular physical activity and intramuscular administration of polysulfated glycosaminoglycans in slowing disease progression (166, 214). However, because OA in adult dogs is often longstanding at the time of diagnosis, interventions aimed at long-term joint protection may be less effective once structural joint changes are well established.
Sustained communication with the owner is essential for effective OA management. Standard assessment tools, such as the CBPI and LOAD questionnaires, can help quantify baseline disease impact, monitor response to therapy, and detect disease progression. Because many therapeutic interventions, particularly analgesic medications, should provide relatively rapid improvement in dogs experiencing OA-related pain, initial follow-up should occur within a few days of starting therapy. This follow-up helps ensure that the owner understands the treatment plan, that the therapy is effective and safe, and that it is practical to maintain over the coming months. If clinical signs are adequately controlled, reevaluation after approximately 3 months may be appropriate. If signs remain poorly controlled, earlier reassessment is warranted. Common causes of inadequate treatment response include persistent inflammation, chronic maladaptive pain, and physical deconditioning. Persistent pain may require adjustment of analgesic therapy or the addition of electrophysical modalities or manual therapy. Physical deconditioning may be addressed through targeted therapeutic exercise, including aquatic therapy (76), and additional ergonomic support. Periodic reevaluation, often on a quarterly basis, helps ensure that management remains effective as the disease progresses.
In summary, OA is common in adult dogs. Its management is complex but can be streamlined through a combination of optimized nutrition aimed at maintaining ideal body condition, appropriate nutritional supplementation, and effective pain control. NSAIDs remain the most predictably effective medications for managing OA-related pain and inflammation. Physical activity is beneficial and should be carefully tailored to minimize symptom flares. Ongoing communication with owners and regular reassessments are essential to maintaining effective long-term management of OA in affected dogs.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank Dr. Joseph J. Wakshlag, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY for his input during manuscript preparation.
Funding Statement
The author(s) declared that financial support was not received for this work and/or its publication.
Footnotes
[内容请查看原文]
Author contributions
DM-L: Supervision, Writing – review & editing, Project administration, Conceptualization, Writing – original draft. JH: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft. TG: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft. APM: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft. MB: Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. DH: Writing – original draft, Writing – review & editing. BF: Writing – review & editing, Conceptualization, Data curation, Writing – original draft, Project administration.
Conflict of interest
BF was employed by Vetoquinol USA.
The remaining author(s) declared that this work was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Generative AI statement
The author(s) declared that Generative AI was not used in the creation of this manuscript.
Any alternative text (alt text) provided alongside figures in this article has been generated by Frontiers with the support of artificial intelligence and reasonable efforts have been made to ensure accuracy, including review by the authors wherever possible. If you identify any issues, please contact us.
Publisher's note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
References
[内容请查看原文]
兽研